waste management审稿意见是significant revision是什么意思?
第一篇文章投稿到waste management,2天进入under review程序,然后就是2个多月的等待。昨天早上收到审稿消息,编辑给的意见是significant revision
The peer review process for your manuscript has been completed. Based on the referee comments, and upon my review of the manuscript, I feel that your paper presents information of interest to the readers of Waste Management but that significant revisions are needed prior to publication.
Please use the attached comments to produce a revised manuscript.
两个审稿人给了意见。
请问这篇文章中的概率大吗?我是小硕,从来没投过这么高级别的期刊,关乎我毕业。。。。。。
谈谈各位的看法。
返回小木虫查看更多
今日热帖
京公网安备 11010802022153号
就是大修咯
significant revision的字面意思是明显的修改,估计修改的难度比较大或者工作量比较大。不过既然给了修改的机会,说明文章有足够新意,参考审稿意见仔细修改,认真回复,修改到位文章就有被接收的希望,
significant revision的含义是比较关键的修改,也就是文章包含的问题不小,可是放心,编辑既然给了大修的机会,这说明人家认可文章的价值,所以你越认真修改,成功率越大,
大修给20天也是蛮紧张的