当前位置: 首页 > 论文投稿 >催稿,编辑回复是凶是吉,求分析。。。。

催稿,编辑回复是凶是吉,求分析。。。。

作者 fenqin
来源: 小木虫 1000 20 举报帖子
+关注

Since at least two of the reviewers had raised very major concerns about the publication of this submission, I have to collect their opinion on the revised paper before reaching my final decision.

I am sorry for a slightly slower review process, which is surely due to the Christmas break.

I will collect all required information by the end of this week and send you the final decision as soon as possbile. 返回小木虫查看更多

今日热帖
  • 精华评论
  • fenqin

    引用回帖:
    8楼: Originally posted by 虫卜1988 at 2017-01-09 20:58:39
    看来只有两个审稿人的意见,估计分歧比较大,编辑在等第三个人的意见。恰巧碰到放假,所以耽搁。他也希望能这个周末能给出决定意见。看不出福祸,但是没有一催就拒稿,那是好事。
    ...

    这是二审了,二审一个月了,接着刚刚的邮件,编辑又发来一封邮件啊。
    Thank you for your email.  We have received one review for your paper and awaiting 2nd review. Second review is also in process and we expect to receive the report shortly. As soon as a decision is reached, we will notify you promptly. Until then, please feel free to contact me should you need further assistance.
    Thank you for your patience. Please help us improve our service by taking this 30 second survey.  
    这是不是系统调查邮件,不能说明什么

  • an_en

    在等另一个审稿人意见呢。我觉得第一个审稿人应该是满意了,否则主编能直接拒你了。

  • andyyiyin

    看审稿人了,目测编辑是和很nice的人,语气还算温和。

  • 好好活着才怪

    这个编辑很负责啊,说的也很明白,他在等消息,是解释原因,而不是说你催稿导致要咋样。我觉得挺好的结果,至少是催稿里面挺好的结果了

  • fenqin

    本周宣判,也不知道做点什么,焦躁的心情啊,估计不会顺利接收,小修什么的吧,或者拒稿。。天啊,是9.22号投稿的,跨年了都。好运砸到我吧,保毕业啊,每天魔怔一样

  • fenqin

    引用回帖:
    13楼: Originally posted by 好好活着才怪 at 2017-01-09 21:41:50
    这个编辑很负责啊,说的也很明白,他在等消息,是解释原因,而不是说你催稿导致要咋样。我觉得挺好的结果,至少是催稿里面挺好的结果了

    谢谢

  • fenqin

    引用回帖:
    12楼: Originally posted by andyyiyin at 2017-01-09 21:40:41
    看审稿人了,目测编辑是和很nice的人,语气还算温和。

    谢谢

猜你喜欢