审稿后编辑拒稿,但拒的不是很直接,大家帮忙看看还有机会重投不?
投的是Applied Catalysis B.
三个审稿人,两个大修,认为还可以,另一个拒稿。
编辑意见如下:
Three reviews of the article by experts in the field are attached below. As is clear from the reviews there are several issues with the experiments, the wavelength of the light source and also the use of a dye in the degradation experiments (See comments by reviewer 1). Potentially, this can be addressed through the use of another (non-dye) organic contaminant. In view of the above, it is deemed that the time necessary to properly revised the manuscript will be too long, hence the decision is to reject in present form. Of course, this is not binding, and I understand that you may opt to submit the paper to another journal.
We appreciate your interest in publishing your work in Applied Catalysis B.
这个期刊没有拒稿重投选项,如果重投,肯定是做为新稿件处理。
大家看看我这种情况还有戏不?谢谢!
我没有几个金币
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
按照审稿意见修改后,重投吧。肯定有戏,一定要认真修改
我觉得你可以改后重投,投的时候说明一下是resubmission就可以了!态度诚恳点没问题的!
祝你成功 !
。
梢孕薷暮笾赝叮险婊馗疵恳桓鲆饧龊侠淼慕獯稹S绕涫悄歉鼍芨宓纳蟾迦耍煤没馗础�
不过还是要做好悲剧的准备,一般拒稿的文章重投给机会的概率相对低一些。好好写cover letter,