当前位置: 首页 > 论文投稿 >关于Required Reviews Completed的状态!

关于Required Reviews Completed的状态!

作者 crazydr
来源: 小木虫 300 6 举报帖子
+关注

我的文章16-6-3投稿,16-7-7即进入Required Reviews Completed状态,到今天已半个月,状态依旧如此。当然自己也是比较着急的盼望好消息早点出现,每天至少上投稿系统查询3-5次。
今天在国外网站交流查询,发现两个回答人气较高的帖子,挺好,分享给大家,希望对大家都有所帮助或者提示吧。帖子如下:

Comment 1.
It doesn't even necessarily mean that all reviews are completed. Sometimes editors invite more reviewers than is required. This message only means that the configured lower bound has been reached.

Comment 2.
The status you see means that the reviewers have submitted their reports to the online system, and the handling editor has received an email about this. Now he /she has to read the comments (and likely look at your manuscript again to see if they comments are relevant), come to a decision, and write a corresponding letter to the author summarizing the comments and justifying the decision. This will in general not take more than an hour.

But you should keep in mind that yours is not the only manuscript (nor, in all likelihood, the only journal) the editor has to deal with. In addition, this is both the end of semester and conference season in many parts of the world, so it is reasonable to assume that the editor is just very busy with more urgent deadlines, or isn't even in office. (Remember, editors are unpaid, so this work is on top of the regular duties of teaching, advising and doing their own research.) In some cases, the final decision even involves two editors (associate/managing editor and editor-in-chief/communicating editor), which doubles the chance of other things getting in the way.

In light of that, I would say two weeks is definitely too early to worry and start contacting the editor; give it at least a month.

 返回小木虫查看更多

今日热帖
  • 精华评论
  • 我来学习的

    很全面,感谢楼主!

  • crazydr

    所以,综上所述:
    Never check the status of your paper. You don't have any bearing on the process anyway!

  • 秋后蚂蚱

    请问楼主最终在这个状态下等了多久?

  • 秋后蚂蚱

    引用回帖:
    5楼: Originally posted by crazydr at 2016-11-09 11:42:47
    等了一个半月多,最后8月31日major revisions
    ...

    谢谢回复,祝你的文章都顺顺利利

猜你喜欢