请教各位前辈小妹投Nano letter悲剧,可否改投ACS nano?
投Nano Letters,两位编辑Philip Kim和Chun Ning Lau共同决定不送审,并且建议改投其他杂志as a full article. 请教各位前辈,这种情况可以改投ACS Nano吗?
若改投ACS Nano,回答投稿系统关于是否投过其他期刊时需要附上Nano letter编辑的意见吗?
附编辑意见:
套话。。套话。。套话。。While the manuscript reports solid experimental work on transferring CVD graphene for metal oxide hybrid devices, we believe that the work at this stage represents only incremental advances and hence is better suited for other journals as a full article. In addition to myself, your manuscript was also read carefully by Associate Editor Chun Ning Lau, who has concurred.
多谢各位虫友
返回小木虫查看更多
今日热帖
京公网安备 11010802022153号
we believe that the work at this stage represents only incremental advances 。。。
这种评价的话投ACS Nano送审的机会也非常小的。建议改投它刊,
ACS Nano和Nano letter一个档次,楼主还是别试啦
想试就试试呗,被拒也就几天就完了。
可以试试,没有必要附上Nano letter编辑的意见,这两个期刊初审很快的。
顶
虽然Nano letter比ACS nano强一点,但实际上档次差不多,根据编辑的意见不建议楼主改投ACS nano。