当前位置: 首页 > 论文投稿 >各位前辈指导一下,被拒了,但是给出了被拒的理由,各位看看我应该怎么处理?

各位前辈指导一下,被拒了,但是给出了被拒的理由,各位看看我应该怎么处理?

作者 chenxiangmo
来源: 小木虫 300 6 举报帖子
+关注

各位前辈指导一下,被拒了,但是给出了被拒的理由,各位看看我应该怎么处理?

是修改重投,还是改投?修改重投要不要写个说明,或者给编辑回信?拒我的编辑正好是我这个方向上的大牛,引用了他4篇文章,而且拒的有点不客气的感觉

Comments from the associate editor:

This submission discusses an application of XXX systems to the modelling and control of an air conditioning system.

Unfortunately, the papers suffers from the following major drawbacks:

- According to the introduction, the paper contains a substantial generalisation of XXX systems. Generalisations in Sections 3-4 are, however, unclear, if any. Most importantly, they lead to system (16) which is still in the XXX form.

- The air conditioning model in Section 5 is very simple. Furthermore, as far as I understand, a very basic state-feedback controller has been used. How it has been tuned? Why the author did not use MPC, which is the standard for XXX systems? Overall, the impact of the paper in the field of energy efficiency for buildings seems limited.

- The paper contains several unclear sentences. For instance, in the introduction: "Althogh there are many models of XXX systems for these applications, these instances are based only on some specified objects. No lecture proposes a universal modelling and controlling to fit many fields, moreover, extends the framework in theotical research."

Overall, I therefore  think the paper is not suitable for publication in XXX(期刊名). 返回小木虫查看更多

今日热帖
  • 精华评论
  • ieem

    应该是编辑没有送审就拒了。拒稿一般不会客气。。。

  • nwu_eact

    都是事先准备好的模板,不用理他啊,继续改投他刊

  • chenxiangmo

    引用回帖:
    2楼: Originally posted by ieem at 2016-04-21 18:30:09
    应该是编辑没有送审就拒了。拒稿一般不会客气。。。

    对,编辑直接拒搞的,有何高见,接下来怎么办

  • chenxiangmo

    接下来怎么办啊,各位

  • kigeon

    给的建议ms挺中肯,先改进再投其它刊物呗

  • outside_chen

    改投其他期刊吧

猜你喜欢
下载小木虫APP
与700万科研达人随时交流
  • 二维码
  • IOS
  • 安卓