当前位置: 首页 > 论文投稿 >拒稿重投有必要吗?还是改投他家

拒稿重投有必要吗?还是改投他家

作者 zuo-jing
来源: 小木虫 650 13 举报帖子
+关注

审稿意见回来如下:
“Your manuscript entitled ", has been reviewed. The reviewer comments are included at the bottom of this letter.
I regret to inform you that the reviewers have raised serious concerns, and therefore your paper cannot be accepted for publication . However since the reviewers do find some merit in the paper, I would be willing to reconsider if you wish to undertake major revisions and re-submit, addressing the referees' concerns. These comments will be made available to reviewers, so please ensure that no identifying information is included in your response.
Please note that resubmitting your manuscript does not guarantee eventual acceptance, and that your resubmission will be subject to re-review before a decision is rendered.
You will be unable to make your revisions on the originally submitted version of your manuscript. Instead, revise your manuscript using a word processing program and save it on your computer.
Because we are trying to facilitate timely publication of manuscripts submitted to the British Journal of Guidance and Counselling, your revised manuscript should be submitted by 23-Feb-2017. If it is not possible for you to submit your revision by this time we will consider your paper as a new submission. ”
看样子是让大修,但是稿件中的状态是“Reject & Resubmit ”。
想知道这种情况下,有必要修改后在投吗?还是我干脆在投一个新的杂志。
如果改投别的杂志需要跟这个写信说明撤稿吗? 返回小木虫查看更多

今日热帖
  • 精华评论
  • wangxf6361

    1)编辑给了楼主修改后重新投稿的机会,还说明了是相当于大修,说明编辑还是认可楼主的文章的。2)编辑给出了截止日期,要在截止日期前尽早修回。3)如果这个期刊属于楼主所在行业比较知名的期刊,建议楼主采纳编辑意见,按照审稿意见好好修改,毕竟这样有利于楼主快速发表自己的论文。good luck~

  • zasxcdcd

    如果这是好杂志,我强烈建议重投,既然编辑给机会了,说明你的水平基本上可以达到杂志的要求,既然是自己辛苦做的成果,当然有必要找个好的归宿。
    按照审稿人和编辑的意见好好修改,截止日期前投回去,一般编辑还会找原来的审稿人重新审稿的。

    最后附上一张我的文章被拒重投的经历,与楼主共勉。
    拒稿重投有必要吗?还是改投他家
    experience.png

  • 贤呦

    引用回帖:
    3楼: Originally posted by zasxcdcd at 2016-03-18 21:20:23
    如果这是好杂志,我强烈建议重投,既然编辑给机会了,说明你的水平基本上可以达到杂志的要求,既然是自己辛苦做的成果,当然有必要找个好的归宿。
    按照审稿人和编辑的意见好好修改,截止日期前投回去,一般编辑还会 ...

    请问是两次Reject都给的重投吗?最近也在挣扎要不要重投、、、、

  • meihai3166

    我也是经历过两次大修,一次小修的。。编辑给了大修就说明有机会

  • zasxcdcd

    引用回帖:
    4楼: Originally posted by 贤呦 at 2016-03-19 11:08:56
    请问是两次Reject都给的重投吗?最近也在挣扎要不要重投、、、、...

    编辑当时给的信里说的是:
    As Journal does not have a major revision category, we are rejecting your manuscript. However, if you feel that you can strongly address the major criticisms of the reviewers, we invite you to resubmit your revised paper as a new manuscript.

  • crazydr

    建议好好修改后重投,几率还是蛮大的。和major revision差不多

  • keryuki

    是这样,根据我领域内一些杂志的规定,即使你转投他处,也必须注明:该稿件曾经在何处被拒过,并且你还要附上上次的审稿意见。如果不这样做,好像歪果仁会认为属于学术不端。

    所以我觉得换杂志不意味着更容易

猜你喜欢
下载小木虫APP
与700万科研达人随时交流
  • 二维码
  • IOS
  • 安卓