当前位置: 首页 > 论文投稿 >各位前辈,近期投稿,一审两位评审给出各自意见,请各前辈指点一下是否是被接受的节奏

各位前辈,近期投稿,一审两位评审给出各自意见,请各前辈指点一下是否是被接受的节奏

作者 daxia1025
来源: 小木虫 1050 21 举报帖子
+关注

晚辈新人,近期投稿,一审两位评审给出各自意见,请各前辈指点一下是否是被接受的节奏以及下一步注意事项,感谢大家,祝福大家

Your manuscript has been reviewed by two referees.

You will see that the reviewers indicated several corrections and additions needed before this paper can be accepted.
Please refer to the following comments.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Reviewer 1: This article seems to have some problems such as 1) forcible technique and 2) no experiment about active pure compounds. In addition, the significance of beginning the study from the prescriptions is not clear. Authors might be better to begin the study from crude drugs.

Reviewer 2: In Tables 1, 3, and 4, and line 10-11 in page 1, 2nd paragraph in page 3, “batch no.” may be mistake of “Product No.”. In usual, these extract granule products has 6 digits batch number ex. J29992. Batch number is assigned to a production lot and the lot size containing the individual products manufactured with a particular production recipe. The products which belongs to the same batch number are expected to be having exactly the same properties. 返回小木虫查看更多

今日热帖
  • 精华评论
  • daxia1025

    引用回帖:
    7楼: Originally posted by 694349361 at 2016-03-01 19:43:53
    第二个reviewer属于小修,将批号这些小错误修改就行。
    第一个reviewer强调技术问题,好好回答,向他解释清楚。

    万分感谢您的回复

  • daxia1025

    引用回帖:
    8楼: Originally posted by godsonlau at 2016-03-02 03:21:08
    评阅人1的不是很好改,不过也大致指出了一个修改方向,这需要你结合论文看看怎么改可以事半功倍一点,因为提到了研究意义,必须认真对待。评阅人2的就是挑了一些细节问题,对应修改就是,但是记得修改说明中要详细说 ...

    非常感谢您的回复,我回继续加油的

  • qsdxueyuan

    好好修改,接收肯定没问题,

  • daxia1025

    引用回帖:
    11楼: Originally posted by qsdxueyuan at 2016-03-02 09:34:59
    好好修改,接收肯定没问题,

    好的,明白了,万分感谢您的回复

  • fage198306

    好好修改肯定会被接受的,祝楼主好运

  • xly19854525

    趋势是良好的,加油

  • 齐大大

    同为新人,但感觉楼主有戏,按照审稿人的意见逐条认真回复,就算有困难无法完成,也要向审稿人说明。

  • daxia1025

    引用回帖:
    13楼: Originally posted by fage198306 at 2016-03-03 09:42:10
    好好修改肯定会被接受的,祝楼主好运

    万分感谢啊

猜你喜欢
下载小木虫APP
与700万科研达人随时交流
  • 二维码
  • IOS
  • 安卓