审稿意见中的两句话的意思
请大虾帮我解释下下面两句审稿意见的意思
1、The approach used by *** et al. is similar to what has been done by others and I have no scientific issues concerning the techniques or their findings. The conclusion is almost self-evident given ***. I would question is any other conclusion was made.
2、 I am, however, requesting that the authors explain why they feel the 3D structure is of any relevance.
返回小木虫查看更多
今日热帖
京公网安备 11010802022153号
第一句是觉得你们的文章涉及的内容已有类似报道，结论也很明显。(审稿人想: 要不是这个结论我才感到奇了呢) 第二句是希望你阐述一下为什么你研究的三维结构值得研究。总之，审稿人觉得文章的内容或写作欠新意。
审稿专家整体觉得研究没有什么新意，创新型不够
谢谢，金币只能发给前一个人，不好意思
，