大神们来看看!!这算是拒稿还是大修?
On the basis of the reviewers’ appraisals and my own careful study of your manuscript, I have decided that your manuscript is not suitable for publication in the Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry in its present form. However, your research has some positive components. I would consider a thoroughly rewritten manuscript, with substantial modification, incorporating the reviewers points and including any additional data they recommended.
If you choose to resubmit, please mention your previous manuscript by JF# in your cover letter, and include an itemized list of changes addressing reviewer comments. A special link to be used when you resubmit can be found on your Paragon Plus homepage, under the heading "Revisions and Resubmissions Requested by Editorial Office".
When submitting your revised manuscript, please be sure the following points are addressed:
Manuscript Format: Manuscripts are to be double-spaced and line-numbered. A separate summary or conclusion section is not to be used; any concluding statements are to be incorporated under Results and Discussion. Please make sure to remove any track changes, highlights, comments or font colors in your manuscript file.
TOC Graphic: The TOC graphic must be included. Authors of research articles, perspectives, and reviews are required to include a suitable graphic for publication in the table of contents (TOC) in the Web edition of the Journal. This graphic should capture the reader’s attention and, in conjunction with the manuscript’s title, give the reader a quick visual impression of the type of chemistry described. The TOC graphic may be up to 4.7 in. (12.0 cm) wide and 1.8 in. (4.6 cm) tall. (See detailed instructions at the Paragon Plus Web site.) Text should be limited to labels for compounds, reaction arrows, and figures. The use of color to enhance the scientific value is encouraged. The TOC graphic should be inserted on a separate page at the end of the manuscript file.
Your resubmission is due in two months.
If we do not receive it before this time, it will become inactivated and you will not have access to it from your Paragon Plus homepage. Please let us know if you need an extension before this time.
Reviewer comments are included below.
It has been a pleasure working with you on this manuscript, and we wish you success in your research.
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
拒了重投
大修,认真对待,好好修改,抓住机会!
但看编辑的话是据稿鼓励重投;再看你的截图系统,很显然是大修。
楼主还是要按照具体的comments进行修改的。
祝福!
是拒稿重投。为了提高投稿数量、降低录用率,老外这一点蛮恶心的(就像饭店一盘菜,已经端上来了,再回一下锅,能变成另一道菜吗?);不过比起来国内某些自命权威的无良期刊那种拖上N个月,然后用一两句话打发投稿人的做法还是要文明一些,后者实在是太LIUMANG了。
拒稿重投的意思,好好按照修改意见修改,还是有很大概率会中的,我遇到过好几次,最后都中了,祝福
看审稿人的意见,要大刀阔斧的修。。。。。感觉跟重写一遍差不多
审稿人的意见很多,而且不太好回答,这样修改后能行么
,