请各位高人给看看论文修改意见,具体神马意思?谢谢啦
论文是关于颗粒运动方面的,论文主体偏重于数值模拟(论文中颗粒模型部分,稍微简介了一下计算理论),有一定的试验辅助。回稿意见不多,但是总感觉看不太懂?第一次写外文论文,请给位大神帮帮忙,
Review comments:
Reviewer #1: In this paper segregation of binary granular matter is simulated and verified by comparison with real experiments. The paper deserves for further consideration. However, in its current version we do not have any chance to learn about computational aspects of these studies. Which numerical method is used to integrate Newton's equations of motion? Does numerical algorithm applied ensure numerical stability? Is the total energy of the systems constant during simulation?
返回小木虫查看更多
今日热帖
京公网安备 11010802022153号
计算原理和方法、模型要介绍�
谢谢,第二个问号要怎样回答合适呢?审稿人是想确定分析方法的稳定性吗?
你得告诉人家用的算法是稳定的
首先,谢谢您的回答。再有就是直接说还是采用什么手段回答他的问题呢,我用的是离散单元法模拟颗粒运动,这种方法一直都是适用和稳定的啊,就像牛顿定律一样,要怎么证明呢
,
投的哪个杂志?
International Journal of Modern Physics B 抱歉回复晚了 论文去年八月已经出刊了