SCI 投稿,编辑给的Decision sent to author,请前辈们看一下,不太明白
编辑回Decision sent to author,我的论文在学术上存在什么问题,请给位前辈指点一下。
Thank you for submitting your manuscript entitled "Mathematical Principles about the Mass of the Moving Object with the Velocity Changes". However, we regret that we are unable to offer to publish it in ours.
As you may know, in deciding which papers to publish, we have to make an editorial judgement about the immediacy of interest to our readers, and the degree and nature of the advance demonstrated. In practice, this means that we decline a majority of manuscripts without sending them to referees, in cases where we feel that, even if referees were to certify the manuscript as technically correct, there would not be a sufficiently strong case for publication in ours. And I am sorry to have to say that we must take this view concerning your submission.
We have no doubt that your findings will be of inherent interest to fellow specialists. But I regret that we are unable to conclude that the paper provides the sort of conceptual advance in scientific understanding that would be likely to excite the immediate interest of researchers in a broad range of other areas of physics. We therefore feel that the present paper would find a more appropriate outlet in a specialist journal, rather than us.
I am sorry that we cannot respond more positively, and I hope that you will rapidly receive a more favourable response elsewhere.
Yours sincerely,
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
就是拒稿呗
谢谢,大哥能给分析一下编辑对于文章的看法就更好了
已经拒稿了。
editor一般没什么意见,你这封信就是个模板套话,不用管他,重点看reviewer的comments
就是委婉地拒稿。
达不到该期刊的发表要求,也就是你的文章水平距离本期刊要求的水平有一定差距吧
非常感谢,谢谢了
,