JOC修改后投稿,将近一个月没有回音!
本人最近投美国化学会JOC一篇, 具体流程如下:
2015,8, 4 投稿
8,6 安排到副主编 (Your manuscript has been forwarded to Dr. Kozlowski )
8,25 Revision Requested for Manuscript ID jo-2015-01803r
大概意见如下:
主编意见:
Thank you for submitting your manuscript for publication in The Journal of Organic Chemistry. Your manuscript has been examined with the assistance of expert reviewers who have evaluated its scientific merit and potential for interest to the readership of the JOC. I have also reviewed your manuscript in my office in light of their comments. On balance this assessment is positive although some revisions are recommended. I am pleased to invite you to submit a revised manuscript that addresses the concerns raised by the reviewers.
三个评审:
Reviewer: 1
Recommendation: Publish in The Journal of Organic Chemistry after minor revisions.
Reviewer: 2
Recommendation: Too fragmentary for publication.
Reviewer: 3
Recommendation: Publish in The Journal of Organic Chemistry after minor revisions.
2015-9-12, 修改稿投出
一般ACS都是10来天就有回复了. 但是,到今天为止已经30天了,还没有接到JOC副编辑回复,不知情况怎么样?
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
也许再等几天可能就有消息了。我们这边有篇一审只用18天,二审花了30天。
可能正好审稿人忙或者暂时外出忘了上传意见。
JOC如果一般给修改机会,最终结果会是比较正面的,除非修改得很不让原审稿人满意。
我的第一篇文章已经悲剧三次了,这次想投JOC,请问楼主,这个期刊新颖性要求高吗
楼主 文章最后接受了吧 返回去多少天有结果的啊
新颖性要求不高 系统性很重要
,
后面修改说明后,接收了
文章已被RSC advances接收