请问edl,这个状态没有审稿人意见,是什么意思
Your manuscript EDL-2015-entitled "" has been given extensive consideration and it has been decided that although the work may be worthy of eventual publication, the manuscript in its present form must be rejected for MAJOR REVISIONS.?
Your manuscript has been denied publication for the following reason(s):
* No persuading argument is included in the introduction.?
* Unique contribution, technical advances from this work should be clarified with specific results.?
* Also, supporting experimental results are very important (should be included) instead of just describing the mechanism.?
However, we would like to encourage you to consider preparing a new version of your manuscript in which the above objections have been overcome. The revised version would be treated as a new manuscript, and would go through the peer review process.?
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
?Editor Immediate Reject - Major Revisions & Resubmit (21-Sep-2015)?Expires on: 20-Sep-2016
这个是拒了还是什么啊,,,怎么没有审稿人意见和啊。。要睡不着了
Resumit其实跟major revision差不太多
至少说明你的文章还是有创新比较interesting的 你需要补做实验 重新写一下文章 然后再选这同一个编辑
谢谢,编辑是韩国三星电子实验室的,应该做的方向和我一致但是我就疑惑了,under review 了两个礼拜,决定了两个礼拜,结果审稿人意见都没发给我。难道说就编辑一个人审稿么
,