AIP advances投稿疑问
第一次投AIP advances,审稿意见如下,是据搞呢还是修改。
Your manuscript, referenced below, has been reviewed for publication in AIP Advances:
Comments from the reviewer(s) are included below.
Unfortunately, we conclude that the manuscript is not acceptable in its present form.
If you are willing and able to respond to each of the reviewer(s)' critical comments, we will consider a revised manuscript. We ask that you submit it by 08-Sep-2015. Please include a rebuttal letter that addresses each point and indicates how the manuscript has been revised.
Reviewer Comments:
Reviewer #1 Evaluations:
RECOMMENDATION: Publish with mandatory revision (minor)
Original Paper required: Yes
Well Organized and Clear required : No
Free From Errors required : No
Conclusions Supported required : Yes
Satisfactory English required : Yes
Appropriate Title required : Yes
Good Abstract required : Yes
Clear Figures required : Yes
Adequate References required : Yes
Reviewer #2 Evaluations:
RECOMMENDATION: Publish with optional revision
Original Paper required: Yes
Well Organized and Clear required : Yes
Free From Errors required : Yes
Conclusions Supported required : No
Satisfactory English required : Yes
Appropriate Title required : Yes
Good Abstract required : Yes
Clear Figures required : Yes
Adequate References required : No
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
修改 认真修改应该问题不大。
是大修还是小修呢
第二个审稿人意见是
RECOMMENDATION: Publish with optional revision
是什么意思呢
,
认真修改一下吧,也算是一个好的机会
文章修改好了,把审稿人意见全都回答了中的可能性很大!楼主赶紧修改完投稿。
就是给你个修改的机会,好好把握!
楼主请问你的AIP多久审稿意见回来的,能麻烦贴一下状态变化吗?我投了一篇AIP advances都快一个月了还在编辑手中,不是说这个杂志很快嘛……