OE没送外审被拒,要申诉吗?
各位大侠,求助
第一次投稿,投OE,一个月后没有送外审,直接被拒,邮件是这样写的
Dear Dr. xx
After editorial review, I have determined that I cannot accept your paper for publication in Optics Express.
A paper is acceptable for publication in Optics Express only if there is convincing evidence that, in addition to being correct technically, it also adds a new and important result to the field. I have found that your paper does not meet this criterion.
I suggest a journal like Applied Optics, more suitable for your manuscript.
Thank you for submitting your paper to Optics Express. I regret that it is not possible to send you a more favorable report on this manuscript, and I hope that you will continue to consider Optics Express for future submissions.
Sincerely,
Patrice Camy
Associate Editor, Optics Express
查Patrice Camy这个人不是我文章领域的,老板让给主编写信说明情况,要求找相关领域的审稿人审稿。
有没有人遇到类似情况,该怎么办?
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
都没有外审怎么申诉呢?申诉编辑?
感觉这个编辑好奇葩,一般拒了就回让你改投其他期刊。这里感觉还贬了一下applied optics,真是够了~
请问你的文章有没有进入peer review阶段?我的投稿后三天进入peer review阶段但是一直没有分配审稿人!
申诉有结果吗?要不要等很久,我昨天申诉了,也是没有外审,但拖了一个月直接给拒了。拒稿理由有点意思,说我们文章是之前投稿文章的延续,之前投稿的文章已经外审被拒,但实际上,我们的文章是第一次投稿。没有抱什么希望,就想了解一下情况,感觉郁闷,如果因为这样直接拒稿,也不用一个月,因为不满所以申诉,但已经在准备改投了,