第一次投sci,被拒了,编辑发的邮件看不懂,大家帮我看看
论文状态是:rejected,拒绝原因是:Unfortunately, I could go through your paper, and although the topic is indeed interesting and your approach might be of interest, I am afraid that your work is still unmature for publication in this journal. Theoretical advance is not enought and conclusions are basically supported from a few examples. In these circumstances your paper cannot be accepted for publication in ***. 邮件里面又说Note that you may resubmit the paper at a later date but there needs to be a rebuttal at the start of the paper referencing this paper with paper ID and title and a clear description of the modifications that you have made to the paper for us to be able to reconsider the paper for publication. We may or may not be able to enlist the help of the original associate editor and reviewers in this context but we will do our best to do so.
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
比大修低一级,但是还有机会,加油改吧
终于懂啦,嘿嘿
看到邮件的rejected, 当时就有点绝望了,不过经过虫友分析后,瞬间就有动力了,加油加油!
确实喜欢这个期刊的话,补充数据,好好大修,重投回去,提以前的投稿号,很有希望送回原来的编辑和审稿人。
我不这么认为,编辑给的状态就是reject,但在邮件中表达了可以再接收的机会,我不太明白你的改后重投会比大修的机会高
,
符合期刊主旨 就是内容可能不够充实吧
内容需要改改 没有大问题的 好好改改重新投稿 祝好!