今天收到了一篇文章的审稿意见：一个审稿人 Publish as is，意见只是总结了一下文章的创新点，没提哪里需要修改；另一个审稿人直接Reject，意见是英语太差，又提了几个表达不清楚的地方。编辑cannot accept the article，但是网站上的状态是Waiting for Revised Manuscript from Author。请问大家这种情况时怎么回事啊？我应该是修改后再提交，还是转投别的期刊呢？如果修改，在文章内容上审稿人也没提什么问题，也只能提高一下英语表达，这样就再提交回去可以么。这个还有希望吗？

Your paper has been reviewed by two reviewers. While one referee provided a generally favorable review, the other had significant criticisms on your paper and recommend your article be rejected. In view of their recommendations, I cannot accept the article.

If you take exception to the reviewers' comments, however, you are welcome to upload a Rebuttal/Response Letter. Log in and follow the link to revise your existing manuscript and upload your Response Letter.

I regret that I am not able to send you a more favorable report at the present time.

The revised manuscript should be uploaded promptly. If you are unable to meet the 120 DAY REVISION DEADLINE, you must submit a new manuscript (new receipt date will be given) and refer to your previous submission (include manuscript number) in the cover letter. In your cover letter please explain what is new relative to the old submission including a detailed list of modifications made in response to the reviewer and editor's comments.

Reviewer Comments:
Reviewer #1 Evaluations:
Recommendation: Publish as is
Technically sound: Y
New ideas: Y
Just a variation of known device or technique: Y
Appropriate journal: Y
Proper context with related work: Y
Clear explanation: Y
Adequate references: Y
Suitable title: Y
Adequate abstract: Y
Significant numerical quantities: Y
Clear figures with captions: Y
Excessive text or figures: Y
English satisfactory: Y
Regular Article vs Note: Regular Article

Reviewer #2 Evaluations:
Recommendation: Reject
Technically sound: N
New ideas: N
Just a variation of known device or technique: Y
Appropriate journal: Y
Proper context with related work: N
Clear explanation: N
Adequate references: Y
Suitable title: Y
Adequate abstract: Y
Significant numerical quantities: N
Clear figures with captions: N
Excessive text or figures: N
English satisfactory: N
Regular Article vs Note: N/A 返回小木虫查看更多