做的修饰电极催化甲醛方面，感觉在13/14年比较火，投EA存有一丝侥幸心理，其实知道自己文章比较烂，没什么太大的新意，只是想看看会不会有审稿意见，因为第一次投稿，没什么经验，想长点见识，结果没想到太悲催了，编辑直接就给拒了，理由Your paper has been subjected to preliminary screening for possible publication in Electrochimica Acta. This new procedure has been adopted  due to the very large influx of papers attracted to the journal as a consequence of its recent excellent performance. Given the remit of the Publisher and the Society, the Editors have the difficult challenge of achieving the highest standards and balanced representation of all areas of electrochemical research. In individual cases, this may be represented by a specific combination of intellectual novelty and/or advances in technological performance.

In its present form we feel that the content of your paper is not showing enough advances in the field of electrocatalysis. In addition, I think that quantifying the merit of a catalyst requires more detailed characterization of the material, such as metal loading, than is done in your study. As a result it is very unlikely that your work be rated among the top 30% of the works accepted in this journal. I recall that Electrochimica Acta aims to publish  high quality papers reporting new developments in Electrochemistry or/and in-depth electrochemical studies.

Consequently, although the work is within the scope of the journal, it does not reach the very high standards now set by the journal and expected by its readers. Under such circumstances I am afraid that your paper has to be rejected. Thank you for giving us the opportunity to consider your work.
看来我的文章不是一般的烂啊 返回小木虫查看更多