投过wiley的另一杂志，编辑处理后，会直接显示under review
一直到审稿结束。
我投的这个杂志确实太慢了， 比elesvier慢

wiley的杂志一般状态一直不变化的    没有必要担心

引用回帖:

Originally posted by jiaqiaojuan at 2010-04-21 16:56:37:
投的先进材料，2周多了，看了一下状态，从提交上去第二天开始到现在都是submitted的状态，最近有人投稿知道先进材料一般多久给回复吗？

估计是悲剧了，刚刚还能看到submitted的状态，发完帖子就找不到文章了

...

wiley的杂志一般状态一直不变化的    没有必要担心

但是你的状况似乎 不妙

可能初审不过  据掉了

应该很快收到 邮件通知的  查查你的邮箱看看

引用回帖:

Originally posted by pumaster at 2010-04-21 19:49:19:

wiley的杂志一般状态一直不变化的    没有必要担心

但是你的状况似乎 不妙

可能初审不过  据掉了

应该很快收到 邮件通知的  查查你的邮箱看看  

收到通知了，一个小改，一个拒，不过拒的人拒得太过分了，准备argue

拒得理由
Where is the originality?

Monodispersed magnetic beads! Various works have reported in such direction

Colloidal stability! Various highly stable particles in salty medium, in various pH etc?have been also reported. Even as a function of time (i.e. low settling velocity)

Magnetic polystyrene beads preparation via dispersion polymerization! The reported process in this manuscript was not so innovating. In fact, Horak et al have already reported the elaboration of magnetic latex particles via dispersion polymerization process. Elaissari et al have also already reported on the elaboration of monodispesed magnetic latex particles.  

Bacteria capturing. This last point will be of great interest if it will be pointed out that such particles enhance the sensitivity of bacteria detection
，

引用回帖:

Originally posted by jiaqiaojuan at 2010-04-21 20:06:52:


收到通知了，一个小改，一个拒，不过拒的人拒得太过分了，准备argue

拒得理由
Where is the originality?

Monodispersed magnetic beads! Various works have reported in such direction

Colloi ...

2周就给了意见？好快啊！太快了 审稿

引用回帖:

Originally posted by Doctorcbw at 2010-04-21 20:09:50:



2周就给了意见？好快啊！太快了 审稿

2周半

我投的维利的期刊一般是两三天变成under review的。楼主的怎么会这样？