【交流】prl审稿,只有一个审稿意见
今年投了一篇prl,我只是觉得有点意思,但没想过发prl。后来老板要试试prl。
10天后顺利送审, 后来只回一个审稿意见,编辑催了其他人多次,都不见回。编辑可能不想等了,历时共70多天。这个审稿人意见很正面,I think these results could be important for ... and will be of interest to general readers of PRL,推荐发表,主要问题是英语不好。
编辑信:
The above manuscript has been reviewed by our referee(s). We ask you
to consider the enclosed comments from the report(s).
While we cannot make a definite commitment, the probable course of
action if you choose to resubmit is indicated below.
( ) Acceptance, if the editors can judge that all or most of the
criticism has been met.
(x) Return to the previous referee(s) for review if available.
(x) Submittal to new referee(s) for review.
With any resubmittal, please include a summary of changes made
and a brief response to all recommendations and criticisms.
不是说prl至少两个审稿意见吗?一个难道就可以?
返回小木虫查看更多
京公网安备 11010802022153号
还不知道呢,现在就先好好改了,
是这样的,前段时间我同一个牛人讨论过.
他说现在的PRL已经改了,速度更快.
以前是一定要等两个审稿人的意见.现在只要其中一个审稿意见回来是postive的话.编辑就可以决定了.主要是编辑喜欢你的文章就可以了.
强烈祝贺啊!PRL不容易的啊.找个英文牛的改改英文喽,应该不成问题.
祝贺,先好好改改,应该没问题
太强大了,楼主
很难啊, 看编辑的决定是要重新找审稿人,还要送回原来审稿人看的
恭喜恭喜!!PRL绝对是要请客的!!
恭喜恭喜,应该问题不大,就怕返回去以后再送给别审稿人。不过楼上几个说的很对,编辑喜欢你的文章是最主要的。
( ) Acceptance, if the editors can judge that all or most of the
criticism has been met.
(x) Return to the previous referee(s) for review if available.
(x) Submittal to new referee(s) for review.
从这个看,编辑要送给原来审稿人看,另外还要找新的审稿人,