24小时热门版块排行榜    

查看: 8648  |  回复: 12
当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖,点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

文点刀王

新虫 (初入文坛)

[交流] sci审稿回复,两个大修后接受,一个拒稿,这种情况怎么办?已有9人参与

这是主编的回信内容:
A and C say accept after major changes, while D says reject. If you resubmit, I will need a revised paper and a point by point response to the referees, especially Ref D.
审稿人A说了一句:“Interesting paper with a new approach for failure load prediction.However there are several major issues to solve:.........”
审稿人D的审稿内容:
It  is  difficult for the  reviewer  to  fully  understand  the  scientific  problem  encountered  by  the authors  and  the  method  proposed  to  solve  the  problem.  The  problem seems to  be  wrong defined. The scientific level is quite low. Scarf joints are already well known from a general aspect. The article is not well suited at all with no specific new idea.
Some remarks can be made to improve the paper:
-  The references are not well suited and not enough detailed
-  The summary don’t well define the contents of the paper
-  Edge effects are not considered in the stress distribution of the adhesive
-  Non uniform stress distribution should be studied
-  It is necessary to number the equations and to quote them in the text
-  Some figures are necessary to fully explain the talking (see remarks in the paper)
-  Finite element analysis should be done again
-  The experimental is incomplete : i.e. influence of the temperature ?
-  It is necessary to explain how the stress tensor is used to characterize the behaviour of the adhesive. The explication is not enough.
这个态度好像很坚决,是什么原因?他第一条就说我们的文献有问题,难道是因为我的文献里面没有他的文章才会这样吗?关键是我也不知道他是谁呀?
这个怎么回复呀?
另外顺路请大家帮忙下载两篇Taylor and Francis Online的文章,都是审稿人A要求参考的
Measurement of the mechanical properties of structural adhesives in tension and shear over a wide range of temperatures
作者a Silva, LFM (Da Silva, LFM); Adams, RD (Adams, RD)
JOURNAL OF ADHESION SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
卷: 19 期: 2 页: 109-141
DOI: 10.1163/1568561053148449
出版年: 2005

3D Modeling of the Elastic-Plastic Behavior of Thin Aeronautical Adhesive Films Suited for a Wide Range of Tensile/Compression-Shear Loads
作者:Maurice, J (Maurice, Julien)[ 1,2 ] ; Creac'hcadec, R (Creac'hcadec, Romain)[ 2 ] ; Cognard, JY (Cognard, Jean-Yves)[ 2 ] ; Davies, P (Davies, Peter)[ 3 ] ; Meirinhos, G (Meirinhos, Georges)[ 1 ] ; Mahdi, S (Mahdi, Stephane)[ 1 ]
JOURNAL OF ADHESION
卷: 89 期: 9 页: 727-751
DOI: 10.1080/00218464.2012.750580
出版年: SEP 2 2013
非常非常感谢
回复此楼

» 猜你喜欢

» 本主题相关价值贴推荐,对您同样有帮助:

已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

ioudan1017

新虫 (著名写手)


小木虫: 金币+0.5, 给个红包,谢谢回帖
我遇到过相同情况,也是两个同意刊登,一个不同意,最后主编拒稿了!然后我就按评审意见修改了稿件,写了申诉信给主编,主编接受申诉,又重新找人审了,最后稿件接收了!

[ 发自小木虫客户端 ]
10楼2014-09-01 22:01:01
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖
相关版块跳转 我要订阅楼主 文点刀王 的主题更新
普通表情 高级回复(可上传附件)
最具人气热帖推荐 [查看全部] 作者 回/看 最后发表
[教师之家] 调查发现:中国高校教师压力,世界第一 +3 nandi2212 2025-01-18 3/150 2025-01-22 00:15 by zju2000
[教师之家] 知名教授博导也是同一理念反复变换说法混成果 +3 河西夜郎 2025-01-20 3/150 2025-01-22 00:00 by zju2000
[教师之家] 学校开始砍本科专业 +12 zylfront 2025-01-17 16/800 2025-01-21 23:53 by zju2000
[考研] 南京工业大学/招收化工、材料和能动方向硕士研究生 +4 jianxiant 2025-01-21 8/400 2025-01-21 21:51 by jianxiant
[硕博家园] 感谢大伙的开导和安慰 +9 山雨亦奇 2025-01-19 10/500 2025-01-21 18:36 by 缘ch
[教师之家] 寒假大家会牺牲过年的时间写本子吗 +11 艾克斯奥特曼 2025-01-19 17/850 2025-01-21 07:14 by csyky2007
[考博] 2025材料申博 +4 梁艺艺 2025-01-20 8/400 2025-01-20 22:33 by CQ_2021Z
[硕博家园] 唉,再不毕业就不想读了。真是进退两难 +20 山雨亦奇 2025-01-19 31/1550 2025-01-20 19:25 by oputweb
[硕博家园] 认为自己没有能力和脑子读博士,不想读博士的人 +20 201725404 2025-01-15 35/1750 2025-01-20 17:53 by 边城一浪子
[教师之家] 2024年,学院无核心期刊论文,有几部专著 +4 河西夜郎 2025-01-17 7/350 2025-01-20 16:10 by daxuefeifei
[硕博家园] 南方科技大学赵天寿教授课题组招聘博士 +3 serieux 2025-01-16 4/200 2025-01-20 09:32 by serieux
[教师之家] 高校领导会对老师制定难以理解的考核要求,这个是服从性测试吗? +6 艾克斯奥特曼 2025-01-19 8/400 2025-01-20 08:57 by 杜慕黑
[论文投稿] 论文校稿阶段,可以修改参考文献格式吗 5+4 afeiii1 2025-01-18 9/450 2025-01-20 08:38 by 六两废铜
[教师之家] 高被引论文背后的暗箱操作 +6 zju2000 2025-01-15 6/300 2025-01-19 08:43 by 张开翅膀的鱼
[考研] 调剂 +3 gshsneid 2025-01-18 3/150 2025-01-18 17:29 by sccd00
[基金申请] 自然基金申请可以网上填写了吗? +4 thirds 2025-01-17 5/250 2025-01-17 12:54 by pityzhou
[硕博家园] 购买化学品 +3 feb20 2025-01-17 8/400 2025-01-17 11:25 by lesgodless
[论文投稿] 审稿人要求补充超级电容器的循环性能,但正文已给出 50+3 时雨巛2023 2025-01-15 8/400 2025-01-16 15:57 by 时雨巛2023
[教师之家] 在审文章怎么撤稿? +4 jurkat.1640 2025-01-15 6/300 2025-01-16 10:45 by eseayl
[论文投稿] Neurocomputing 审稿rrc持续18天 +3 mollyzhang_2003 2025-01-15 5/250 2025-01-16 10:42 by mollyzhang_2003
信息提示
请填处理意见
商务合作商务合作
商务合作二维码商务合作咨询微信扫一扫(备注:商务合作)
学术干货学术干货
学术干货二维码微信扫一扫了解最新学术干货
论文辅导论文辅导
论文辅导二维码微信扫一扫添加老师,免费咨询
师资招募师资招募