| 查看: 1837 | 回复: 6 | |||
[交流]
clean-soil,air,water什么情况，修改前都快接收了，最后拒稿？
|
|
类似经验：http://muchong.com/bbs/viewthread.php?tid=4402131 昨晚看到这篇帖子，结果今天就悲剧了，大家看看吧，求安慰，求建议！ 1. On clen.201200236.R1: Editor: Bandyopadhyay, Amitava Comments to the Author: The reviewer comments are now available that suggest minor revision. I have also read the MS and it is more or less acceptable. But I am unable to accept the authors following response: "The trends of OMA formation efficiency are similar in other experiments conducted with different initial oil concentrations. However, there are only two representatives’ been described. Because putting all data in same figure will make it difficult to read." Authors must show such variation : Shaking time (x-axis) vs E% (y-axis) at various oil concentration (at least four) for the two types [in an additional Fig (a) & in Fig (b)]. A few lines may be added in the relevant portion of the text (R&D Section). The manuscript is still require some revision as described above. 2. On clen.201200236.R2 Comments to the Author: The manuscript can now be acceptable considering the extent of revision made by the Authors. For clarity, minor corrections/changes are however, suggested on the manuscript which is attached. The authors have made a great effort. Thanks to them. 3. On clen.201200236.R3 The paper has been substantially corrected now. However, three minor corrections as noted are to be incorporated. Attached is your submitted revised version with those corrections indicated thereto. Show a sample calculation for the ratio of mineral to dispersed oil as indicated in the relevant portion of the text. Thanks for your great effort. 4. For clen.201200236.R4 The manuscript has not been revised in accordance with the requirements of our Journal and hence it is recommended that the Manuscript be rejected. 都按照要求改了，不知道怎么最后就给了这么个结论！主编貌似也是不看的，每次都是cc给这个Editor: Bandyopadhyay, Amitava 主编回信：I am sorry to inform you that your revised manuscript, "Enhanced Oil-Mineral Aggregation with Modified Bentonite", has not been found acceptable for publication in "CLEAN - Soil, Air, Water". The journal receives many more manuscripts than it can publish and difficult decisions must be made on the basis of an article's perceived priority. Your manuscript did not achieve a high enough ranking to be accepted. While disappointing, I must emphasize that this decision is final. 不知道该如何申诉~~~请大牛给意见。 [ Last edited by lisa1985 on 2012-8-22 at 12:39 ] |
回复此楼» 猜你喜欢
今年春晚有几个节目很不错，点赞！
已经有12人回复
-
情人节自我反思：在爱情中有过遗憾吗？
已经有13人回复
-
体制内长辈说体制内绝大部分一辈子在底层，如同你们一样大部分普通教师忙且收入低
已经有12人回复
-
过年走亲戚时感受到了所开私家车的鄙视链
已经有9人回复
-
基金正文30页指的是报告正文还是整个申请书
已经有5人回复
» 本主题相关价值贴推荐，对您同样有帮助:
- JPS投稿接收了
已经有26人回复
- WM with editor 一个月，正常吗？
已经有3人回复
- 投desalination and water treatment，如何知道投稿是否成功？
已经有6人回复
- 圣诞前一天文章莫名其妙被拒稿，申诉成功后今天戏剧接收
已经有231人回复
- 因为语言等细节问题被拒稿，修改后重投给原来的杂志收的可能性大么？
已经有9人回复
- 【Pure water】I am happy that they are very busy.
已经有9人回复
- 请问：修改稿如果不按照审稿人的意见修改，会被拒掉么
已经有14人回复
- 文章接收后修改投稿单位
已经有12人回复
» 抢金币啦！回帖就可以得到:
-
坐标广州，征女友
+2/130
-
天津科技大学海洋与环境学院殷焕顺团队招博士生1名---分析化学领域
+1/81
-
一个陌生女人的来信
+1/58
-
大连海事大学轮机学院尚有博士名额
+2/54
-
海法大学线上开放日
+1/33
-
国家级青年人才课题组招收2026级硕士研究生
+1/30
-
国家级青年人才课题组招收2026级硕士研究生
+1/28
-
代朋友发 88公务员诚征男友
+1/17
-
2026年天津科技大学“新能源催化与膜材料团队”研究生招生
+1/17
-
太原理工大学集成电路学院招收2026年博士研究生
+1/6
-
南昌大学资源与环境学院刘进教授团队招收2026硕博研究生
+1/5
-
中国科学技术大学 工程科学学院 国家级人才团队 诚聘博士后
+1/5
-
全奖博士 英国利物浦大学+台湾清华大学 双博士学位
+1/5
-
天津医科大学基础医学院张恒课题组博士后招聘
+1/4
-
招收2026年入学博士研究生
+1/3
-
内江师范学院能源转化与储能实验室诚聘博士1-2人
+1/3
-
深圳大学26级土木工程博士招生
+1/2
-
澳科大招收2026秋纳米医学/生物材料方向全奖博士研究生（3月5日18:00截止）
+1/2
-
武汉工程大学赵庆彪教授招收博士生
+1/2
-
武汉工程大学化学与环境工程学院赵庆彪教授招收2026级博士生
+1/1
2楼2012-08-22 11:10:00
3楼2012-09-14 19:10:10
4楼2012-09-14 22:04:15
5楼2012-09-14 22:20:24
6楼2012-09-14 23:16:42
7楼2012-09-14 23:17:42