24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

ningkefeng

银虫 (初入文坛)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 355.8
帖子: 34
在线: 25.3小时
虫号: 830698
注册: 2009-08-19
专业: 人工智能与知识工程

[求助] 帮忙看看审稿意见（IEEE Trans. Neural Networks and Learning Systems）已有2人参与

请有经验的投过该期刊的帮忙看下。谢谢。

副主编的意见。

Recommended Decision by Associate Editor: Recommendation #1: Major Revision

Comments to Author(s) by Associate Editor:
Associate Editor
Comments to the Author:
Based on the comments of the reviewers, my decision is that the paper requires minor revisions as indicated by the reviews. The authors need to prepare a new version of the paper by carefully addressing all issues raised by the reviewers.

审稿人的意见如下：

Individual Reviews:

The paper overall evaluation Grades are: 5 or 4 or 3 or 2 or 1.
Grade 5 indicates EXCELLENT contribution while Grade 1 indicates WEAK/USELESS contribution.
Reviewer: 1
Overall Evaluation: 4
Reviewer: 2
Overall Evaluation: 3
Reviewer: 3
Overall Evaluation: 3

++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Reviewer(s)' Comments to Author(s):

Reviewer: 1

Comments to the Author
The topic is interesting and timely. However, several imporvements are needed:
1) The contribution and originality should be stressed
2) The motivation of the study should be clearly presented
3) Discussion of related work must be expanded. For example, there are papers on using interval type-2 fuzzy systems or type 2neuro fuzzy to produce prediction intervals
4) There are typos and grammar errors
5) More references to related work could be included, for example:
Oscar Castillo, Juan R. Castro, Patricia Melin, Antonio Rodríguez Díaz: Universal Approximation of a Class of Interval Type-2 Fuzzy Neural Networks in Nonlinear Identification. Adv. Fuzzy Systems 2013 (2013)
Martha Pulido, Patricia Melin: A New Method for Type-2 Fuzzy Integration in Ensemble Neural Networks Based on Genetic Algorithms. Recent Advances on Hybrid Intelligent Systems 2013: 173-182
Juan R. Castro, Oscar Castillo, Patricia Melin, Olivia Mendoza, Antonio Rodríguez Díaz: An Interval Type-2 Fuzzy Neural Network for Chaotic Time Series Prediction with Cross-Validation and Akaike Test. Soft Computing for Intelligent Control and Mobile Robotics 2011: 269-285
Juan R. Castro, Oscar Castillo, Patricia Melin, Antonio Rodríguez Díaz: A hybrid learning algorithm for a class of interval type-2 fuzzy neural networks. Inf. Sci. 179(13): 2175-2193 (2009)



Reviewer: 2

Comments to the Author
- In my opinion this paper should be accepted with minor revision.
- The authors should consider the following comments:

- More references should be included at least 30
- The conclusions should be extended
- The number of formulas in my opinion should be reduced and only include the most importants

Reviewer: 3

Comments to the Author

This paper is very interesting; however some comments are suggested to improve the quality of your paper. The comments are described as follows.

- More recent references to related work are needed.
- Improve the quality of the graphics, the results of the simulations are not appreciated.

回复此楼