两个审稿人,第一个语气挺友好,虽然提了8条具体意见。
第二个一上来就说大修,然后提了6条具体意见。
This manuscript deals with interesting experiments as regards XXXX. However, the description of the manuscript is not clear and compact. In addition, the reasoning leading to the conclusion from the experimental results is not clear at all. Major revision is needed.
(1) XXX
(2) XXX
(3) XXX
(4) XXX
(5) XXX
(6) Each time illustration of a figure is given, should state so at the beginning of explanation. (就这一点看不懂啊)