| 查看: 505 | 回复: 1 | |||
[求助]
英文杂志审稿意见样本
|
| 一英文杂志（IONICS）要本人为其审稿，不知从何入手。哪位高手有审稿意见样本，能否给小弟参考一下？多谢在先 |
回复此楼» 猜你喜欢
27年电化学博士毕业，想找海外QS前50的高校读博后求推荐
已经有3人回复
-
27年电池/材料类博士申请
已经有2人回复
-
物理化学论文润色/翻译怎么收费?
已经有117人回复
-
2027年博士申请或转博科研助理 求推荐
已经有1人回复
-
请问谁有2025最新影响因子Excel表？金币求助！
已经有53人回复
-
氯化钠与有机磺酸分离
已经有1人回复
-
瑞典-博后-固态电池-粘结剂-锂离子电池方向
已经有53人回复
-
广东省面上有什么动态么，啥时候公布呀？
已经有1人回复
-
高盐废水电催化氧化，氯离子存在下活性氯副产物、阳极选型的工程困惑
已经有0人回复
» 本主题相关价值贴推荐，对您同样有帮助:
- 哪位高人能帮我看看这个审稿意见是什么意思？
已经有11人回复
- 怎么回复中文期刊的审稿意见，有没有模板啊？
已经有4人回复
- 【教程】如何巧妙回复英文期刊编辑审稿意见【视频】
已经有185人回复
- 求审稿周期短又好发的英文杂志！急急急
已经有8人回复
- 投英文杂志审稿意见居然是中文！！！！
已经有65人回复
- 第一次投英文期刊，在送给编辑审稿之前就被退回来了，呜呜！投的Tetrahedron Letters
已经有6人回复
- 可以用中文回复国内英文期刊审稿意见吗？
已经有6人回复
- 【求助】英文期刊的审稿意见看不懂什么意思
已经有9人回复
- 高分子加工审稿快的英文期刊有哪些？
已经有4人回复
- 审稿意见回来了，更正数据会造成什么样的影响
已经有26人回复
【答案】应助回帖
滴水书生(金币+5): 2011-07-14 10:38:33
|
Manuscript Number: SSSCIE Title: New Lithium rechargeable batteries - Electrochemical performance of Chelation aided sol-gel synthesized nano-sized spinel LiMn2O4 and LiMxMn2-xO4: (M=Cr, Al; x=0.0-0.4) as a cathode materials coupled with doped Lithium nitride anodes Reviewers' comments: This paper reports the synthesis of nano sized particles of LiMn2O4 and LiMxMn2-xO4: (M=Cr, Al; x=0.00-0.40) using phthalic acid and fumaric acid as chelating agents by sol-gel method. The results seem to be valid, but this reviewer cannot see any originality in this paper. And this reviewer don not agree some explanations of this paper. 1. Page 4 “This solution was stirred continuously with gentle heating till to obtain a homogenous mass.” What is the temperature of gentle heating? 2. Page 4 What is the molar ratios between phthalic acid/fumaric acid and total metal ions? Why are this molar ratios between phthalic acid/fumaric acid. 3. Page 6 “The following multiple weight loss regions observed between 200–700oC corresponding to weight loss of 55% is associated with the decomposition of the acetate precursors and chelating agent.” In my opinion, it should include the loss of water of chemical bond water in the sample. 4. Page 8 The ionic radius of Mn4+ is 0.53 Å, but the ionic radius of Mn3+ depends on the spin state. In the low spin state (LS) the ionic radiuses is 0.58 Å, but in the high spin state (HS) its ionic radius is 0.645 Å (not 0.72 Å  [R. D. Shannon, Acta Crystallogr., A32 (1976) 751.].5. Page 9 Crystallinity (i.e. crystal domains size) can be evaluated from peak width, but there is not peak width in this paper 6. Page 9 The LiMn2O4 powders calcined at 250 and 450 oC show sub-micron sized particles below 50nm with uniform morphology. In my opinion, the nano-sized material can not be seen by SEM. 7. Page 10 In my opinion, the nano-sized material can not be seen by SEM. 8. Page 10 The nano-sized material is difficult to be seen from Fig.8 and Fig.9 9. Page 11 “In the case of samples with higher Al-doping (0.40) good agglomerated particles were observed which would be beneficial for better electrochemical performance.” Several authors have reported that spinel lithium manganese oxide with agglomerated particles has worse electrochemical performance. Reference: [X.M. Wu et al., Ceram. Int. (2007), doi: 10.1016/ j.ceramint. 2007. 03. 024] [Ben-Lin He et al Electrochimica Acta 52 (2007) 3286–3293] [Tingfeng Yi, et al. Journal of Power Sources, 162(2006) 636-643] 10. Fig.12 The capacity of spinel lithium manganese oxide begins to fade after 50 cycles, but the cycle number of spinel lithium manganese oxide in the paper is only 10 cycles. 11. Page 15 “LiCr0.1Mn1.90O4 spinel exhibits slightly higher cathodic peak current (1.75mA) when compared to the un-doped one (1.45mA).” The cathodic peak current is also different due to the weight of the electrode or surface area. Considering the above points, regrettably, my opinion is that the manuscript is NOT suitable for publication in the Solid State Sciences |
2楼2011-07-13 21:11:29
