[交流] sci审稿回复，两个大修后接受，一个拒稿，这种情况怎么办？ 已有9人参与

这是主编的回信内容： A and C say accept after major changes, while D says reject. If you resubmit, I will need a revised paper and a point by point response to the referees, especially Ref D. 审稿人A说了一句：“Interesting paper with a new approach for failure load prediction.However there are several major issues to solve:.........” 审稿人D的审稿内容： It  is  difficult for the  reviewer  to  fully  understand  the  scientific  problem  encountered  by  the authors  and  the  method  proposed  to  solve  the  problem.  The  problem seems to  be  wrong defined. The scientific level is quite low. Scarf joints are already well known from a general aspect. The article is not well suited at all with no specific new idea. Some remarks can be made to improve the paper: -  The references are not well suited and not enough detailed -  The summary don’t well define the contents of the paper -  Edge effects are not considered in the stress distribution of the adhesive -  Non uniform stress distribution should be studied -  It is necessary to number the equations and to quote them in the text -  Some figures are necessary to fully explain the talking (see remarks in the paper) -  Finite element analysis should be done again -  The experimental is incomplete : i.e. influence of the temperature ? -  It is necessary to explain how the stress tensor is used to characterize the behaviour of the adhesive. The explication is not enough. 这个态度好像很坚决，是什么原因？他第一条就说我们的文献有问题，难道是因为我的文献里面没有他的文章才会这样吗？关键是我也不知道他是谁呀？ 这个怎么回复呀？ 另外顺路请大家帮忙下载两篇Taylor and Francis Online的文章，都是审稿人A要求参考的 Measurement of the mechanical properties of structural adhesives in tension and shear over a wide range of temperatures 作者a Silva, LFM (Da Silva, LFM); Adams, RD (Adams, RD) JOURNAL OF ADHESION SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 卷: 19 期: 2 页: 109-141 DOI: 10.1163/1568561053148449 出版年: 2005 3D Modeling of the Elastic-Plastic Behavior of Thin Aeronautical Adhesive Films Suited for a Wide Range of Tensile/Compression-Shear Loads 作者:Maurice, J (Maurice, Julien)[ 1,2 ] ; Creac'hcadec, R (Creac'hcadec, Romain)[ 2 ] ; Cognard, JY (Cognard, Jean-Yves)[ 2 ] ; Davies, P (Davies, Peter)[ 3 ] ; Meirinhos, G (Meirinhos, Georges)[ 1 ] ; Mahdi, S (Mahdi, Stephane)[ 1 ] JOURNAL OF ADHESION 卷: 89 期: 9 页: 727-751 DOI: 10.1080/00218464.2012.750580 出版年: SEP 2 2013 非常非常感谢

回复此楼