24小时热门版块排行榜    

查看: 5017  |  回复: 13
当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖,点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

foolishstar

木虫 (小有名气)

[求助] 收到初审意见了,大家说录用的可能性有多大? 已有5人参与

元旦收到文章的初审意见,有三个评审,有两个人很明确,支持发表,有一个也很明确,反对。原话如下:
1 Reviewer #1: The******** is a quite interesting topic, worth to be addressed in a systematic way.
The paper is well written, the experimental procedure is described (with some missing details as outlined below) and the experimental uncertainties are reported.
As far as the discussion and conclusions are concerned, in my opinion some points have to be clarified as suggested below.
In summary, I consider the paper worth to be published in Applied Thermal Engineering, provided the following amendments are carried out:
(下面是具体修改意见)
2 Reviewer #2: This paper reports ***********. The topic is very interesting. It is recommended that the manuscript be accepted, subject to however a major revision.
(下面是具体修改意见)
3 Reviewer #3: The paper is focused on*******. For this purpose the Authors consider that the proposed new index *****.
However, there are two weaknesses:
1. The innovative part is not clear; what new the article has to add in the ATE?
2. The Author's proposed system is very similar to an existing techno-commercial system.
In particular the Authors do not explain the originality of their approach and of their results with respect to the literature data.
In conclusion the paper is of low scientific quality and neither well presented and organized. Therefore the present manuscript is not suitable for publication in ATE.
(下面没有了)
我感觉第三个人没好好看,因为他说的我的论文的弱点不是我的主要的东西。但是我应该怎么跟他讲呢?
另外,大家说如果按照要求修改了,发表的几率多大?
谢谢
回复此楼

» 猜你喜欢

» 本主题相关价值贴推荐,对您同样有帮助:

已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

fox_fm3

金虫 (正式写手)

引用回帖:
7楼: Originally posted by foolishstar at 2014-01-01 17:08:42
如果修改返回,前两个人录用,第三个还是反对,那咋整啊?...

不用担心那么多,你回答的好,审稿人也是通情达理的
关键还是论文的质量,把你的特色突出出来,他说和别人的一样,你就要说出来不一样的地方,有理有据
但是要顾及他的面子,别说的太僵,先肯定他说的有道理,然后说自己的理由,或者说自己赞同他的观点,文章中也有体现,只是可能由于自己的原因没有说清楚之类的

» 本帖已获得的红花(最新10朵)

9楼2014-01-01 17:23:10
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖
查看全部 14 个回答

南海猪

金虫 (著名写手)

The only one

【答案】应助回帖

感谢参与,应助指数 +1
尽最大努力认真修改吧~总不能撤稿吧~楼主加油~早日accept~

[ 发自手机版 http://muchong.com/3g ]
出来混,不是你帮我就是我帮你~~~
2楼2014-01-01 16:41:14
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

nono2009

超级版主 (文学泰斗)

No gains, no pains.

优秀区长优秀区长优秀区长优秀区长优秀版主

【答案】应助回帖

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★
感谢参与,应助指数 +1
foolishstar: 金币+30, ★★★★★最佳答案, nono这样说,心里就有底了! 2014-01-01 17:04:03
ATE这样的审稿意见,好好修改,录用基本没问题。
3楼2014-01-01 16:43:26
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

vect

至尊木虫 (著名写手)

【答案】应助回帖

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★
感谢参与,应助指数 +1
foolishstar: 金币+10, ★★★很有帮助, 是啊,要谨慎。就是第三个人我不大知道该怎么回应,他的问题其实在文章中说过,我要么再跟他强调下?这样会不会对他不大尊重的感觉?他下次再审还是给拒了咋办啊? 2014-01-01 17:05:50
希望很大,前面两个都interesting,这个评价比较高了
第二个其实是大修,
第三个称论文表达方面不清楚,这些都可以改进,尤其是你要讲清楚你的方法的优点,及跟现有方法的比较
我觉得如果能认真回应的话,中的希望很大
4楼2014-01-01 16:45:29
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖
最具人气热帖推荐 [查看全部] 作者 回/看 最后发表
[考博] 售一区SCI文章T0P,我:8O.551.O54,科目全,可十急 +5 XJXMuRjD7cK7 2026-11-13 5/250 2026-11-18 13:22 by UPDUsNlULsJZ
[论文投稿] 售一区SCI文章T0P,我:8O.551.O54,科目全,可十急 +5 XJXMuRjD7cK7 2026-11-13 5/250 2026-11-18 11:43 by Z1pODz48hoDV
[硕博家园] 售SCI一区文章,我:8.O.551.O.5.4,科目全,可伽急 +5 XJXMuRjD7cK7 2026-11-13 5/250 2026-11-18 11:32 by Z1pODz48hoDV
[考研] 售SCI一区文章,我:8.O.55.1.O.54,科目齐全,可伽急 +4 uKOSCocCb6Fm 2026-11-13 4/200 2026-11-18 11:21 by Z1pODz48hoDV
[论文投稿] 售SCI一区T0P文章,我:8O.55.1.O.5.4,科目齐全,可+急 +3 uKOSCocCb6Fm 2026-11-13 4/200 2026-11-18 10:04 by Z1pODz48hoDV
[考研] 售SCI一区T0P文章,我:8.O.55.1.O.5.4,科目全,可+急 +4 uKOSCocCb6Fm 2026-11-12 9/450 2026-11-18 09:06 by Equinoxhua
[公派出国] 售一区SCI文章T0P,我:8O.551.O54,科目全,可十急 +4 uKOSCocCb6Fm 2026-11-12 8/400 2026-11-18 08:58 by Z1pODz48hoDV
[教师之家] 征友后感触 +4 重新启 2026-11-17 4/200 2026-11-18 08:18 by Leogzhya
[硕博家园] 售一区SCI文章T0P,我:8O.551.O54,科目全,可十急 +4 uKOSCocCb6Fm 2026-11-13 4/200 2026-11-16 11:06 by K7HMGGdOpylw
[公派出国] 售SCI一区文章,我:8.O.55.1.O.54,科目齐全,可伽急 +4 uKOSCocCb6Fm 2026-11-13 4/200 2026-11-16 10:44 by K7HMGGdOpylw
[公派出国] 售一区SCI文章T0P,我:8O.551.O54,科目全,可十急 +3 SX5mJmPWDfOO 2026-11-13 3/150 2026-11-15 08:29 by xSrQNSSjcgoX
[论文投稿] 售SCI一区文章,我:8.O.551.O.5.4,科目全,可伽急 +4 XJXMuRjD7cK7 2026-11-13 4/200 2026-11-15 07:01 by xSrQNSSjcgoX
[硕博家园] 售SCI文章,我:8O5.5.1.O.54,科目齐全,可+急 +4 XJXMuRjD7cK7 2026-11-13 4/200 2026-11-15 06:50 by xSrQNSSjcgoX
[考博] 售SCI文章,我:8O5.5.1.O.54,科目齐全,可+急 +3 uKOSCocCb6Fm 2026-11-12 7/350 2026-11-15 03:32 by xSrQNSSjcgoX
[考博] 27博士申请(市政/环境) +3 ladf 2026-11-12 3/150 2026-11-13 08:19 by Equinoxhua
[公派出国] 售SCI一区文章,我:8O5.5.1.O5.4,科目全,可伽急 +3 TgvkbZZl9tqB 2026-11-11 4/200 2026-11-12 12:48 by ECLTXnJnRSXf
[公派出国] 售SCI一区T0P文章,我:8.O.55.1.O54,科目全,可伽急 +4 cdqGD6ftHmbl 2026-11-11 5/250 2026-11-12 12:28 by ECLTXnJnRSXf
[考博] 售一区SCI文章T0P,我:8O.551.O54,科目全,可十急 +4 cdqGD6ftHmbl 2026-11-11 5/250 2026-11-12 12:28 by ECLTXnJnRSXf
[硕博家园] 售SCI一区T0P文章,我:8.O55.1.O.54,科目全,可十急 +4 cdqGD6ftHmbl 2026-11-11 4/200 2026-11-12 12:26 by ECLTXnJnRSXf
[教师之家] 售SCI一区T0P文章,我:8.O.55.1.O.54,科目齐全,可+急 +3 TgvkbZZl9tqB 2026-11-11 4/200 2026-11-12 08:15 by HajghKOMynmz
信息提示
请填处理意见