| ²é¿´: 1958 | »Ø¸´: 10 | ||
| ¡¾ÐüÉͽð±Ò¡¿»Ø´ð±¾ÌûÎÊÌ⣬×÷Õßfirstluo½«ÔùËÍÄú 10 ¸ö½ð±Ò | ||
firstluo½ð³æ (СÓÐÃûÆø)
|
[ÇóÖú]
PRB ±à¼»ØÐŲ»ÊʺϷ¢±í£¬ÇóÖúÓÐûÓÐÍì»ØµÄ»ú»á£¿ ÒÑÓÐ4È˲ÎÓë
|
|
|
PRB ±à¼»ØÐŲ»ÊʺϷ¢±í£¬µ«ÊÇÎҸоõÂÛÎıȽϳ¤£¬refereeºÃÏñҲûÓÐÈÏÕæ¿´£¬»¹Ö¸³öProbably there is more in the second part of the paper, however, the message is so diluted that it is hard to extract it. ¾ßÌåÒâ¼ûÈçÏ£¬Çë´óÏÀÃDz»Áߴͽ̣¡ ============================================================== Re: XXXX Dear Dr. YYY, The above manuscript has been reviewed by one of our referees. Comments from the report appear below. These comments suggest that the present manuscript is not suitable for publication in the Physical Review. Yours sincerely, XXXX Associate Editor ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Report of the Referee -- XXXXX ---------------------------------------------------------------------- The paper is nicely written. Nevertheless, I am afraid I do not understand the importance of the message and results. The derivation of the ME is pretty standard and the DB comes directly from the properties of the environment. As far as I understand, this is the recipe shown in the books so I am missing the new information here. The results presented indicate that, as it should be, the populations in the steady state are modified. Probably there is more in the second part of the paper, however, the message is so diluted that it is hard to extract it. I think that the paper needs a major revision with the new results highlighted. Personally, I do not consider the derivation of the ME one of them (see standard textbook derivation of the ME). |
» ²ÂÄãϲ»¶
Ò»Ö¾Ô¸AÇø211£¬22408 321Çóµ÷¼Á
ÒѾÓÐ4È˻ظ´
0854Çóµ÷¼Á
ÒѾÓÐ7È˻ظ´
294Çóµ÷¼Á
ÒѾÓÐ5È˻ظ´
327Çóµ÷¼Á
ÒѾÓÐ26È˻ظ´
307ÖÐÒ½¿¼Ñе÷¼Á
ÒѾÓÐ4È˻ظ´
ͨÐŹ¤³ÌÇóµ÷¼Á£¡£¡£¡
ÒѾÓÐ5È˻ظ´
Çóµ÷¼Á
ÒѾÓÐ14È˻ظ´
ҩѧÇóµ÷¼Á
ÒѾÓÐ13È˻ظ´
Ò»Ö¾Ô¸»ªÖÐũҵ071010£¬320Çóµ÷¼Á
ÒѾÓÐ12È˻ظ´
290µ÷¼ÁÉúÎï0860
ÒѾÓÐ43È˻ظ´
finalmusic5
ľ³æ (ÕýʽдÊÖ)
- Ó¦Öú: 48 (СѧÉú)
- ½ð±Ò: 3920.2
- ºì»¨: 11
- Ìû×Ó: 484
- ÔÚÏß: 411.1Сʱ
- ³æºÅ: 2468173
- ×¢²á: 2013-05-17
- רҵ: Äý¾Û̬ÎïÐÔ II £ºµç×ӽṹ
¡¾´ð°¸¡¿Ó¦Öú»ØÌû
¸Ðл²ÎÓ룬ӦÖúÖ¸Êý +1
| ÁÁµãûͻ³ö£¬×öµÄ¹¤×÷ÔÚÉó¸åÈË¿´À´¶¼Êǽ̿ÆÊéÉÏÃèÊöµÄroutineµÄ·½·¨£¬½á¹ûÒ²ÊÇ´ó¼Ò¾ùÒÑÖªÏþµÄ½á¹û£¬·½·¨ºÍ½á¹û¶¼Ã»ÓÐÁÁµã£¬Éó¸åÈË×îºóÒ»¾ä»°ÊǸøÌ¨½×ϵÄÒâ˼¡£¡£¡£ |
2Â¥2015-10-15 14:06:43
firstluo
½ð³æ (СÓÐÃûÆø)
- Ó¦Öú: 1 (Ó×¶ùÔ°)
- ½ð±Ò: 1444.6
- ºì»¨: 1
- Ìû×Ó: 182
- ÔÚÏß: 129.4Сʱ
- ³æºÅ: 127176
- ×¢²á: 2005-12-08
- ÐÔ±ð: GG
- רҵ: Äý¾Û̬ÎïÐÔ II £ºµç×ӽṹ
|
ллר¼ÒµÄ»Ø¸´¡£µ«ÊÇÎÒµÄÂÛÎĵÚÒ»²¿·Öȷʵ²»ÊÇÖØµã°¡£¨ÂÛÎĹ²12page, µÚÒ»²¿·ÖÒ²¾Í1¸öpage£©£¬Ö»µ±ÊÇÑо¿µÄ»ù´¡£»µÚ¶þ²¿·Ö²ÅÊÇÎÒµÄÖØµã£¬µ«refereeÖ»¶Ô²»Ì«ÖØÒªµÄµÚÒ»·Ö²¿½øÐÐÁËcomment£¬¶øÖصãµÄµÚ¶þ²¿·ÖÖ»ÊÇÇáÃèµÐ´Ð´ÁËÕâôһ¾ä»°£¬ºÃÏñ¿´µÃºÜ´Ò棬¸Ð¾õ²¢²»ÊǺÜÈÏÕæ°¡£¡Äú¾õµÃÓÐappealµÄ¿ÉÄÜÐԺͱØÒªÂ𣿠·Ç³£Ð»Ð»£¡ |
3Â¥2015-10-15 14:43:09
zyqh
Ìú¸Ëľ³æ (ÖøÃûдÊÖ)
- Ó¦Öú: 33 (СѧÉú)
- ½ð±Ò: 6714.6
- É¢½ð: 1454
- ºì»¨: 22
- Ìû×Ó: 2380
- ÔÚÏß: 593.5Сʱ
- ³æºÅ: 2762045
- ×¢²á: 2013-10-29
- ÐÔ±ð: GG
- רҵ: Äý¾Û̬ÎïÐÔ II £ºµç×ӽṹ

4Â¥2015-10-15 20:06:26
firstluo
½ð³æ (СÓÐÃûÆø)
- Ó¦Öú: 1 (Ó×¶ùÔ°)
- ½ð±Ò: 1444.6
- ºì»¨: 1
- Ìû×Ó: 182
- ÔÚÏß: 129.4Сʱ
- ³æºÅ: 127176
- ×¢²á: 2005-12-08
- ÐÔ±ð: GG
- רҵ: Äý¾Û̬ÎïÐÔ II £ºµç×ӽṹ
|
×ö¼ÆËãµÄÎÄÕ£º ÂÛÎĵÚÒ»²¿·Ö£ºÑо¿ÁËDB¶Ôϵͳ¶¯Á¦Ñ§µÄÓ°Ï죨Ҳ¾ÍÊÇrefereeËùÆÀ¼Û½Ì¿ÆÊéÉϾÍÄÜÔ¤¼ûµÄ½á¹û£¬µ«Æäʵ½Ì¿ÆÊéÆäʵҲûÓÐ×ö¹ý¾ßÌåµÄ¼ÆËã°¡£¬ÎÄÏ×ҲûÓÐÔõô¿´µ½Ê²Ã´¾ßÌåµÄÓ°Ïì°¡£¬ÎÒÃÇÑо¿·¢ÏÖÓ°ÏìÆäʵÊǷdz£´óµÄ£©£» ÂÛÎĵڶþ²¿·Ö£ºDB¼ÈÈ»ÕâÃ´ÖØÒª£¬Òò´ËÎÒÃÇ·¢Õ¹ÁËÒ»ÖÖÌØ±ðµØUNR·½·¨£¬¸Ã·½·¨Äܹ»ÔÚÍ×ÉÆ´¦ÀíDBЧӦµÄ»ù´¡ÉÏ£¬ÓÃÓÚÑо¿FBC¹ý³Ì£»£¨¶øÄ¿Ç°ÆäËûµÄUNR·½·¨Ñо¿FBC¹ý³Ì£¬¾ùûÓп¼ÂÇDBЧӦ£©£»Òò´ËÎÒÃÇ·¢Õ¹µÄUNRΪDBЧӦµÄ»ù´¡ÉϵÄFBC¹ý³ÌÌṩÁËÒ»ÖÖÖØÒªµÄ·½·¨£» ÂÛÎĵÚÈý²¿·Ö£ºÊýÖµ¼ÆËãÑéÖ¤ÁËÎÒÃÇÌá³öµÄUNR·½·¨µÄÈ·Äܹ»´¦ÀíDBЧӦ»ù´¡ÉÏFBC¹ý³Ì£¬¶øÇÒ½á¹ûºÜÀíÏë¡£ ²»ÖªµÀrefereeÔõô¾ÍÊDz»ÆÀÂÛÂÛÎĵĵڶþ¡¢Èý²¿·Ö£¬¾ÍÖ±½Ó¸ù¾ÝÂÛÎĵĵÚÒ»²¿·Ö²Ý²ÝÏÂÁ˽áÂÛ£¿ÊÇËû±¾Éí²»¸ÒÐËȤ? Çë²»Áߴͽ̣¡ лл£¡ |
5Â¥2015-10-15 21:17:14
qqgod
Ìú¸Ëľ³æ (ÕýʽдÊÖ)
- Ó¦Öú: 3 (Ó×¶ùÔ°)
- ½ð±Ò: 9097.2
- É¢½ð: 29
- ºì»¨: 1
- ɳ·¢: 2
- Ìû×Ó: 435
- ÔÚÏß: 851.2Сʱ
- ³æºÅ: 677145
- ×¢²á: 2008-12-18
- רҵ: ¹âѧ
¡¾´ð°¸¡¿Ó¦Öú»ØÌû
¸Ðл²ÎÓ룬ӦÖúÖ¸Êý +1
| PRB±¯¾çÁ˾ÍתͶ±ðµÄÔÓÖ¾°É¡£PRϵÁеÄÉó¸åÈËÓÐʱºòϲ»¶ÂÒ˵¡£µ«ÄãÄÃËûÃÇҲûÓа취¡£ÊÂʵÉÏPRϵÁÐÉϺܶàÎÄÕµķ½·¨ºÍ½á¹û¶¼Ã»ÓÐÁÁµã£¬¾ÍÊÇ»»¸öϵͳÓÖ×öÒ»±é£¬»¹Æ«ÉúºÃ·¢¡£Ðµķ½·¨ºÍ˼·һ°ã¶¼±»Éó¸åÈËÅúÒ»¶Ù¡£ÎÒÃÇ×éÈ¥ÄêÊî¼ÙһƪÎÄÕ±»PNAS½ÓÊÕÁË£¬ÕâÆªÎÄÕÂǰÄêÄêµ×µÄʱºòÏÈͶPRL±¯¾ç£¬×ªÍ¶PRA±»Éó¸åÈËÂÒÅúÒ»¶Ù£¬¾¹È»Ò²±»¾ÜÁË¡£µÚ¶þÌì¸Ä¸ñʽͶPNAS£¬Õâ»ØÓö¼ûÁËÄÚÐУ¬´óÐÞÁËÁ½»ØÖÐÁË¡£Ä¿Ç°SCIÒýÓÃ20+¡£¸Ð¾õPRϵÁеÄÉó¸åÈ˺ܲ»¿¿Æ×¡£¿ÉЦµÄÊÇǰ²»¾Ã³öÀ´Ò»ÆªfollowÎÒÃÇÎÄÕµĹ¤×÷·¢±íÔÚPRAÉÏ£¬»¹ÊÇEDITORS' SUGGESTION¡£ |
6Â¥2015-10-15 22:56:41
gindar
гæ (ÕýʽдÊÖ)
- Ó¦Öú: 3 (Ó×¶ùÔ°)
- ½ð±Ò: 1031.8
- É¢½ð: 1270
- ºì»¨: 11
- Ìû×Ó: 534
- ÔÚÏß: 150Сʱ
- ³æºÅ: 2785223
- ×¢²á: 2013-11-07
- רҵ: º£ÑóµØÖÊѧ
7Â¥2015-10-15 22:59:45
ÄäÃû
Óû§×¢Ïú (ÕýʽдÊÖ)
- Ó¦Öú: 7 (Ó×¶ùÔ°)
- ½ð±Ò: 1485.6
- É¢½ð: 839
- ºì»¨: 4
- Ìû×Ó: 579
- ÔÚÏß: 257.6Сʱ
- ³æºÅ: 0
- ×¢²á: 2012-03-07
- ÐÔ±ð: GG
- רҵ: Äý¾Û̬ÎïÐÔ II £ºµç×ӽṹ
8Â¥2015-10-15 23:19:40
firstluo
½ð³æ (СÓÐÃûÆø)
- Ó¦Öú: 1 (Ó×¶ùÔ°)
- ½ð±Ò: 1444.6
- ºì»¨: 1
- Ìû×Ó: 182
- ÔÚÏß: 129.4Сʱ
- ³æºÅ: 127176
- ×¢²á: 2005-12-08
- ÐÔ±ð: GG
- רҵ: Äý¾Û̬ÎïÐÔ II £ºµç×ӽṹ
9Â¥2015-10-16 08:24:02
yuzanzier
гæ (СÓÐÃûÆø)
- Ó¦Öú: 1 (Ó×¶ùÔ°)
- ½ð±Ò: 379.9
- ºì»¨: 3
- Ìû×Ó: 148
- ÔÚÏß: 24.7Сʱ
- ³æºÅ: 4133235
- ×¢²á: 2015-10-10
- רҵ: ÒÕÊõѧ
10Â¥2015-10-16 11:32:46













»Ø¸´´ËÂ¥
