24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

grace040802

木虫 (小有名气)

应助: 10 (幼儿园)
金币: 2701.3
散金: 216
红花: 6
帖子: 208
在线: 98.9小时
虫号: 510789
注册: 2008-02-24
性别: MM
专业: 无机非金属基复合材料

[求助] editor 的修改意见有几条怎么回复？

昨天投的稿件，当天晚上就收到editor的major revision的意见。其中有些意见很难以回答故求助之，多谢虫友们！Blessing!!!

A DETAILED ANSWER TO ALL THESE QUERIES MUST BE PROVIDED AS AN ATTACHMENT TO YOUR RESUBMISSION. FAILURE TO DO SO WILL RESULT IN REJECTION OF THE PAPER WITHOUT A TECHNICAL REVIEW.

1.    YOU MUST MAKE SURE YOUR ENGLISH IS READABLE.  If your English is difficult to understand we will REJECT the paper without technical review until it is readable by the reviewer. If you need English assistance you may refer to a English language service who will provide the correction service for a fee

这条是在说我的英语太chinese了. 用什么可以判断文章 is readable by the reviewer? 找个老外来修改文章并注释？

2.    IF YOU DO NOT GIVE A MECHANISM FOR YOUR OBSERVED RESULTS WE WILL REJECT THE PAPER AS NOT BEING OF JOURNAL QUALITY. MECHANISM IS MANDATORY. Conclusions must be comprehensive and not written like a report.  PLEASE ALSO CLEARLY INDICATE THE INDUSTRIAL VALUE/RELEVANCE  FOR THESE APPROACHES DESCRIBED IN YOUR PAPER. Please also state in the first few paras as to why this work is not the same as that of others and what knowledge is it adding that is not already available that contributes to the archival literature 陈述工作与他人不一样的地方。

3.    WE TAKE PLAGIARISM SERIOUSLY. Your similarity report MUST not exceed 5% for us to consider a technical review  http://www.ithenticate.com/, Please use the ithenitcate software to check your paper before submission. 这个软件用它这个链接是要收费的，不知道您是否用过ithenitcate software？

4.    WE RECOMMEND THAT YOU download any of the free articles using this link http://www.tandf.co.uk/journals/cited/LMMP.pdf, Please look through the pdf TABLE OF CONTENTS attachment for other companion papers published in mamp that may assist in the relevance of your paper.

5.    50% of the references must be from the last 5 years.  YOUR PAPER MUST NOT EXCEED 15 TYPED PAGES INCLUDING FIGURES, SO PLEASE REMOVE UNNECESSARY FIGURES AND ENSURE THAT THEY ARE OF THE RIGHT SIZE AND NOT OVERSIZED. IF YOU HAVE TOO MANY PAGES THE PUBLICATION OF YOUR ARTICLE UPON ACCEPTANCE WILL BE DELAYED INDEFINITELY DUE TO SPACE CONSTRAINTS. YOU CAN SHRINK ALL THE FIGURES TO SAVE SPACE. MAKE SURE THAT YOUR FIGURES HAVE PROPER LEGENDS, MICRON MARKERS AND IS REPRODUCIBLE LEGIBLY. WE ALLOW A MAXIMUM AMOUNT OF 3500 WORDS FOR TEXT AND 8 FIGURES/TABLES. ANYTHING MORE THAN THAT WILL BE REJECTED, SO CHOOSE YOUR TABLES AND FIGURES WISELY 共13篇since2009，还差2篇即可满足要求。这个容易搞定。

6.    Only single keywords must be used not combinations of words- e.g, electrode, discharge, machining and not electrode discharge machining. Reference citations must be completely spelt out – NO abbreviations allowed for journal citations. Please reduce the length of your title to no more than 12 words and it MUST emphasize PROCESSING 文章中没有关于process的论述

7.    Please provide email address for each author and at least two different email addresses for the primary point of contact

8.    Your paper must have a significant content ON MANUFACTURING PROCESSES and CANNOT be mere modeling or properties AS IT WILL BE REJECTED- there are other journals to focus on those issues. If there is NO materials content your paper will be REJECTED WE DO NOT ACCEPT PAPERS ON MERE PROPERTIES. There are other journals for that- so make sure there is a strong processing content 这个是一个很大的问题，因为我的文章里面没有process，仅仅只是hot compression。

回复此楼