| 查看: 957 | 回复: 10 | |||
[交流]
一审意见回来，有点吃不准，大家帮忙看看？
|
|||
|
三个审稿意见，两个比较正面，最后一个有点吃不准。编辑给了major revision。 reviewer 1: ...Overall, this is a very interesting and well executed paper. I have some questions and some suggestions for improvement, where the latter ones refer mainly to structure, motivation and readability. As the model is novel and, in my view, adds something important to the literature, the paper could make a valuable contribution to XXXX after a careful revision.... reviewer 1列了七八条意见，但都不太难回答。 reviewer 2: ...To the best of my knowledge, the authors are right that they are the first to carefully analyze a tractable equilibrium model with both belief heterogeneity and prospect-theory preferences. Theorems 1 and 2 are interesting, and so is the empirical exercise in section 4. As explained by the authors, prediction markets constitute a growing toolbox for aggregating probability forecasts. The theoretical literature discussed by the authors has aimed to improve on this toolbox, in part by better understanding the actual behavior of market participants. The present article is a very good contribution to this theoretical literature.... reviewer 2列了18条修改意见，但大部分都是指出一些typo外加一些语言叙述上的建议，总体也还好。 reviewer 3: This paper is interesting and engaging to read. ...The model and market equilibrium appear to be sound and are well-explained. Modelling prospect theory is not my area of expertise but the authors do a good job at explaining this to the non-expert. The paper is technical in nature and appears to be well-executed. I do have a number of substance concerns that that authors might consider. Each of these is discussed further below. The most concerning is whether the FLB or rFLB bias is actually the appropriate lens to empirically test a binary (win/lose or home/away) outcome. In my mind, this is not what the FLB or rFLB is about. ... 我感觉reviewer 3估计对这个topic不是太了解，他对我们的模型的适用性和一些基础假设提出了疑问，但实际上这些假设在领域内算是比较常见的做法。前两位审稿人明显对这个topic比较了解，因此对这些假设没有提出质疑。这种情况下如果我引一些领域内的相关文献来证明假设的合理性，是否有机会扭转reviewer 3的印象？ |
回复此楼» 猜你喜欢
» 抢金币啦！回帖就可以得到:
【招聘】温州医科大学/附属医院/瓯江实验室李校堃院士团队诚聘博士后和科研人员
+1/188
-
陕西理工大学资源与环境、材料化工部分调剂名额，理工兼收
+1/186
-
北京石油化工学院【化学工程与技术、材料与化工】调剂招生3名！
+1/90
-
宜春学院 药学研究生调剂52人
+1/53
-
能源动力专硕（清洁能源技术）接收调剂硕士生
+1/41
-
五邑大学药学与食品工程学院 | 刘宇茸课题组 调剂招生
+5/40
-
沈阳农业大学生物与医药招收调剂生！！！！！！！！！！
+1/32
-
南京林业大学-国家级青年人才团队 招2026级博士、调剂硕士（合成化学方向）
+1/18
-
汕头大学海洋与生命学科李升康教授团队招收生物类调剂生
+1/16
-
烟台大学精准材料高等研究院26年材料方向研究生招生
+1/10
-
化学、化工、化妆品、材料背景考生调剂
+1/6
-
苏州初创公司诚聘化学过程工艺与硬件系统工程师
+1/6
-
哈尔滨工程大学动力学院赵建辉团队招收2026博士研究生
+1/5
-
五邑大学纺织科学与工程学院“智能纺织材料与纺织品”研究团队接收硕士调剂生
+1/4
-
欢迎广大考生调剂到西安工程大学环境与化学工程学院
+1/4
-
2026年云南大学青拔课题组招收地理学，大气科学、资源与环境等专业研究生
+1/3
-
2026年江西科技师范大学化学化工学院隋晓锋课题组招收硕士研究生调剂
+1/3
-
求调剂
+1/2
-
材料成型及控制工程 材料加工工程
+1/2
-
哈工大韩飞课题组招收3D微纳加工、光学工程、纳米化学等方向博士生及博后（长期有效）
+1/1
5楼2021-03-04 23:35:57
3楼2021-03-04 23:29:31
10楼2021-03-05 08:09:56
简单回复
tzynew2楼
2021-03-04 23:28
回复
deaniiiii(金币+1): 谢谢参与
o 发自小木虫Android客户端
bjdxyxy4楼
2021-03-04 23:31
回复
deaniiiii(金币+1): 谢谢参与
。 发自小木虫Android客户端
MTXSCI16楼
2021-03-05 00:33
回复
deaniiiii(金币+1): 谢谢参与
， 发自小木虫Android客户端
awenxm7楼
2021-03-05 06:39
回复
yuekong8楼
2021-03-05 07:07
回复
2021-03-05 07:44
回复
deaniiiii(金币+1): 谢谢参与
1 发自小木虫Android客户端
nono200911楼
2021-03-05 08:55
回复
deaniiiii(金币+1): 谢谢参与
·
