| 查看: 2712 | 回复: 13 | |||
| 当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖 | |||
[交流]
IEEE ACCESS 审稿意见大家帮忙分析分析
|
|||
大家好~第一次投稿，编辑给的意见是建议修改后重投，两个接收，还有一个拒绝（意见很尖锐 ），大家可以帮忙分析下要不要换reviewers（第二个审稿人有点一股脑否定的意思..）下面是三位审稿人的意见： Reviewer: 1 Recommendation: Accept (minor edits) Comments: What additional benefits would this research bring to the readers of this journal? What different this research from the previously published papers on the topic? Additional Questions: Does the paper contribute to the body of knowledge?: Yes. Because Code comments contain valuable information to support software development, especially during code reading and code maintenance. It is very important to classifying code comments for provide better data for program understanding. But please explain what additional benefits would this research bring to the readers of this journal? What different this research from the previously published papers on the topic? Is the paper technically sound?: Yes. Very technically... Is the subject matter presented in a comprehensive manner?: Yes Are the references provided applicable and sufficient?: Most of reference from proceeding/conference. Maybe can include from journal of index. The reader suggests that the authors could collect more publications to enhance all these code comments. Reviewer: 2 Recommendation: Reject (do not encourage resubmit) Comments: It is a novel apporach for understanding the comments from program, however, from the paper, I did not find the most impacted contributions to techniques. While authors of this paper did not clearly defined how this code-comments to texts or sentence classifications. That's what we expect to see how AI or methods understanding and assessments. Additional Questions: Does the paper contribute to the body of knowledge?: Somehow or No Is the paper technically sound?: Somehow or No Is the subject matter presented in a comprehensive manner?: Maybe Are the references provided applicable and sufficient?: Yes Reviewer: 3 Recommendation: Accept (minor edits) Comments: It is a well-presented paper on an important topic about automatic code-comment assesment. Additional Questions: Does the paper contribute to the body of knowledge?: Yes, paper has a contribution to the body of knowledge, it presents a framework for assessment of code comments using Multi Layer Perceptrons. Beside, it also provides a manually annotated dataset for automatic code-comment assessment approaches. Thus, it deserves to ve published. Is the paper technically sound?: The paper is well-wrtiten and well-presented. The methodology and experimentation section gives the appropriate technical details about the methodolodgy proposed. Is the subject matter presented in a comprehensive manner?: The depth of the detail in both data preperation and Dcomment framework they proposed were satisfactory. Besides, it also includes comprehensible literature review on topic. Are the references provided applicable and sufficient?: All major works has been cited. The level of references provided in the paper is satisfactory. 又看了一遍第二个审稿人的意见，我好气哦，感觉不像自己这个领域的...不知道怎么说服他  |
回复此楼» 猜你喜欢
科研好难啊，想退学去打工。
已经有33人回复
-
找工作千万不能来差学校
已经有8人回复
-
审稿人一收一拒，编辑给了修
已经有9人回复
-
优青已经开始了么？
已经有8人回复
-
等盲审
已经有6人回复
-
大家能不能给点意见啊
已经有13人回复
-
小硕盲审没过
已经有17人回复
-
关于公布2024年度国家自然科学基金项目申请初审结果的通告
已经有15人回复
-
博士毕业找工作选择！
已经有10人回复
-
有没有想聊天的
已经有13人回复
» 抢金币啦！回帖就可以得到:
-
88年985博士山西籍，遵义高校教师，合同还有6年，到期可到任何地方工作，诚证北方人。
+3/150
-
湖北汽车工业学院微纳结构与量子器件团队诚聘青年英才，事业编，无非升即走
+1/131
-
深圳信息职业技术学院滨海土木工程技术研究所招聘资源循环利用方向访问学生
+2/109
-
坐标郑州 诚征女友 非诚勿扰
+1/81
-
中科院大连化物所先进生物制造研究部诚聘科研助理博士后
+1/80
-
华南理工大学建筑学院伍志斌教授课题组2024年全职博士招聘
+1/74
-
燕山大学张利鹏教授招收车辆工程专业学术博士1名
+1/74
-
广州征女友
+1/71
-
90后男北京真诚征婚 (征到即删，长期有效)
+1/69
-
东莞理工-中国科大联合博士后招聘
+1/45
-
美国博后，诚征女友
+1/37
-
寻求催化博士后岗位
+1/36
-
中建三局铁投华东公司2024届春季校招建造岗补录
+2/30
-
寻找一女友
+1/27
-
接好运！！南大女副教授毕业6年主持项目经费近1700W，同年获得“优青“和“重点”项目
+1/26
-
浙大研究助理招聘
+1/9
-
天津医科大学(211)药理学系招2024年秋季入学申请考核博士研究生(生命科学背景)
+1/9
-
有机硅低温固化问题
+1/5
-
天津医科大学(211)药理学系招2024年秋季入学申请考核博士研究生(生命科学背景)
+1/4
-
深圳大学特聘教授李凯课题组招聘OLED发光材料与器件研究员/博士后
+1/1
+3/150
13楼2019-12-29 09:53:38
6楼2019-10-27 17:59:54
10楼2019-10-27 18:34:02
11楼2019-10-27 19:08:04
简单回复
一品哥哥2楼
2019-10-27 17:32
回复
wdz18(金币+1): 谢谢参与
， 发自小木虫Android客户端
超级老快4楼
2019-10-27 17:39
回复
wdz18(金币+1): 谢谢参与
q 发自小木虫IOS客户端
2019-10-27 18:33
回复
爱星3楼
2019-10-27 17:39
回复
wdz18(金币+1): 谢谢参与
。 发自小木虫Android客户端
LWJL20198楼
2019-10-27 18:11
回复
wdz18(金币+1): 谢谢参与
。 发自小木虫Android客户端
