24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

ybhan

金虫 (正式写手)

应助: 12 (小学生)
金币: 1429.5
帖子: 598
在线: 111.9小时
虫号: 447427

[交流] PRL审稿意见

三月份投稿了一片Phys.Rev.Lett.四月份得到如下回复：
Dear Prof. XXX,

The above manuscript has been reviewed by our referees.

The resulting reports include a critique which is sufficiently adverse
that we cannot accept your paper on the basis of material now at hand.
We append pertinent comments.

If you feel that you can overcome or refute the criticism, you may
resubmit to Physical Review Letters. With any resubmittal, please
include a summary of changes made and a brief response to all
recommendations and criticisms.

Yours sincerely,

审稿人有两个，一个说很有新意，完全同意发表，另一个说有新意，但是主要观点阐述有问题，不同意我们提出的结论，建议要么按照他说的结论，要么坚持我们自己的但是在PRB上长篇详细阐述。
各位大牛，这样还有戏吗？已经按照第二个审稿人的建议修改重投PRL了，结果又发了3个审稿人，这三个人里面包含有之前审稿过的那两位吗？

14May15 Review request to referee; response not yet received
13May15 14May15 Review request to referee; message received (not a report)
11May15 13May15 Review request to referee; message received (not a report)
11May15 Review request to referee; response not yet received
11May15 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author
10Apr15 11May15 Ed. decision and/or ref. comments to author; response rcvd
04Mar15 10Apr15 Review request to referee; report received
19Mar15 20Mar15 Query to referee; response received
04Mar15 19Mar15 Review request to referee; report received
18Mar15 19Mar15 Reminder to referee; response received
18Mar15 Reminder to referee [others sent (not shown) at 1-2 week intervals]
05Mar15 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author
05Mar15 Right to publish signature received
04Mar15 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author
04Mar15 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author
04Mar15 Acknowledgment sent to author
03Mar15 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author

回复此楼

» 抢金币啦！回帖就可以得到:

查看全部散金贴

1楼 2015-05-19 22:10:07

已阅回复此楼关注TA 给TA发消息送TA红花 TA的回帖

ybhan

金虫 (正式写手)

应助: 12 (小学生)
金币: 1429.5
帖子: 598
在线: 111.9小时
虫号: 447427

引用回帖:

13楼: Originally posted by cmp at 2015-05-19 22:56:42
你理解错了，只送了两个审稿人，应该是原来反对的加上新找的一个。
中间的message received (not a report)只是表示编辑找的那两个审稿人不愿意审，仅此而已。
Good luck！

嗯，也就是说，找了第三个人重新审的，我做的课题比较偏，估计感兴趣的人也不多，所以两个人都不愿意审稿，估计是这样吧