51楼: Originally posted by dwwdww at 2015-01-19 15:43:56
1个borderline，2个weak reject 还要rebuttal吗？

51楼: Originally posted by dwwdww at 2015-01-19 15:43:56
1个borderline，2个weak reject 还要rebuttal吗？

53楼: Originally posted by delphizmy at 2015-01-19 19:34:54
我也是1个borderline，2个weak reject，是不是没有必要rebuttal了，在考虑后面投个workshop不知道有没有戏...

52楼: Originally posted by pandayf at 2015-01-19 17:03:58
我也出来了，三个borderline。。。我也纠结还要不要rebuttal...

54楼: Originally posted by lillllllll at 2015-01-19 20:05:34
我的也一样1borderline,2weakly reject，但有个审稿人要求回复.还是回复一下吧
...

56楼: Originally posted by dwwdww at 2015-01-19 22:02:32
是不是Rebuttal Requests 里面有内容， 都要回复呀？...

55楼: Originally posted by dwwdww at 2015-01-19 21:58:18
三个borderline应该rebuttal吧，希望应该很大...

10楼: Originally posted by joyousrabbit at 2014-11-28 18:16:35
最后结果都差不多，我的算法强调“simplicity”，唯一的比较方法就是读一下我的算法，再读一下别人的算法，难道要我做个表格比较各个算法实现的行数吗？

我就是觉得论文好坏是一回事，要拒也得是reviewer拒，而 ...

15楼: Originally posted by zdw2006yyy at 2014-11-28 22:02:04
一般是有专门的计算算法复杂度的公式的。。不需要比较实现的行数的。。...