²é¿´: 2637  |  »Ø¸´: 12
µ±Ç°Ö»ÏÔʾÂú×ãÖ¸¶¨Ìõ¼þµÄ»ØÌû£¬µã»÷ÕâÀï²é¿´±¾»°ÌâµÄËùÓлØÌû

tuerqier

гæ (ÕýʽдÊÖ)

[½»Á÷] Éó¸åÈ˰ÑÎÒµÄÂÛÎĺÍԭʼµÄnatureÉϵÄÂÛÎͼ±áÁË£¬ÈçºÎÔÚPhysica AÉêËß ÒÑÓÐ6È˲ÎÓë

ÎÒÑжÁÁËһƪ11ÄêNatureÉÏÒ»·âÃæÂÛÎÄARTICLE£¬×öÁËЩСС¸Ä¶¯ºÍ´´Ð£¬Í¶µ½Physica A

È¥Äê7Ô·ÝͶ¸åPhysica A£¬9ÔÂÊÕµ½Ò»ÉóÒâ¼û£¬¾ÍÒ»¸öÉó¸åÈËÒªÇóÐ޸ģ¬È»ºó10Ôµ×Ͷ³öÐ޸ĸå
2ÔÂÊÕµ½ÐżþÔ­À´Éó¸åÈËÕÒ²»µ½ÁË£¬½ÐÎÒÔÙÕÒ5¸öÉó¸åÈË£¬ÎÒҲûÊìÈ˾ÍÔڲο¼ÎÄÏ×ÖÐÕÒÁË10¸ö
¾ßÌå¼ûhttp://muchong.com/bbs/viewthread.php?tid=6951058

½ñÌìÊÕµ½Éó¸åÒâ¼ûÈçÏ£¬°ÑÎÒµÄÂÛÎĺÍԭʼµÄnatureÉϵÄÂÛÎͼ±áÁË£¬¾Í¸øÁËÎÒÆªPlos One
£¨ÄÇÆªPlos OneÎÒд֮ǰ¾Í¿´¹ý£¬ÊÇÖØÐÂÌÖÂÛÁËNatureÉÏÄÇÆª£¬µ«ÎÒû¾õµÃÓÐÖØ´óÍ»ÆÆ£¬ËùÒÔÖ÷Òª²Î¿¼NatureÉÏԭʼ¹¤×÷£©
ÇëÎÊÎÒÕâÖÖÇé¿ö¸ÃÉêËßÂð£¿ÈçºÎÉêËߣ¿Ð»Ð»£¡

Reviewers' comments:

Reviewer #2: This is a sloppy, simplistic, and hastily assembled paper on the structural controllability of networks. The basic model of this paper -- which is derived straight from £¨ÕâÊÇ11ÄêNatureÉÏһƪ·âÃæÂÛÎÄARTICLE£© is a flawed model: a network of integrators.

For example, the modeling approach does not allow for stable dynamics -- the A matrix always has a trace of 0 (sum of e-values is 0). This is just one but a huge host of problems with this vacuous modeling approach. See Cowan et al. for more information:

http://www.plosone.org/article/i ... ournal.pone.0038398

In short, the present paper suffers from the same poorly conceived modeling framework as in the original "seminal" paper by £¨Í¬ÉÏNatureÂÛÎÄ£© and then puts together a simple set of results on this bad modeling paradigm.

Other comments speaking to the poor effort in assembling the manuscript
1) The figures are hard to read
2) the references are so poorly formatted as to be embarrassing. Titles are missing, capitalization is all over the place, and there are references such as [13]
»Ø¸´´ËÂ¥

» ²ÂÄãϲ»¶

» ±¾Ö÷ÌâÏà¹Ø¼ÛÖµÌùÍÆ¼ö£¬¶ÔÄúͬÑùÓаïÖú:

ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

ÉÜÃô¿¤Ö÷

ľ³æ (ÖøÃûдÊÖ)

¡ï
Сľ³æ: ½ð±Ò+0.5, ¸ø¸öºì°ü£¬Ð»Ð»»ØÌû
ÒýÓûØÌû:
3Â¥: Originally posted by tuerqier at 2014-03-17 12:05:11
¹Ø¼üÕâÉó¸åÒâ¼û£¬ÎÒ»ù±¾Á¬ÐÞ¸ÄÓàµØ¶¼Ã»ÓÐ

natureÉÏԭʼ¹¤×÷Òѱ»±á£¬ÎÒµÄССÒýÉ껹Ôõô¸Ä°¡...

ÄǾͱȽÏÂé·³ÁË¡£
¸ÄͶµÄ»°¿ÉÒÔ×¢Ã÷¡°²»ÍƼö¡±ÄǸöÈË×öÉó¸åÈË¡£
4Â¥2014-03-17 13:14:46
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû
²é¿´È«²¿ 13 ¸ö»Ø´ð

ÉÜÃô¿¤Ö÷

ľ³æ (ÖøÃûдÊÖ)

¡ï
Сľ³æ: ½ð±Ò+0.5, ¸ø¸öºì°ü£¬Ð»Ð»»ØÌû
natureÉϵÄÂÛÎÄÒ²²»Ò»¶¨ÊÇÍêÃÀµÄ£¬¹Ø¼ü¿´Éó¸åÈË˵µÄÓÐûÓеÀÀí
2Â¥2014-03-17 11:45:56
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

tuerqier

гæ (ÕýʽдÊÖ)

ÒýÓûØÌû:
2Â¥: Originally posted by ÉÜÃô¿¤Ö÷ at 2014-03-17 11:45:56
natureÉϵÄÂÛÎÄÒ²²»Ò»¶¨ÊÇÍêÃÀµÄ£¬¹Ø¼ü¿´Éó¸åÈË˵µÄÓÐûÓеÀÀí

¹Ø¼üÕâÉó¸åÒâ¼û£¬ÎÒ»ù±¾Á¬ÐÞ¸ÄÓàµØ¶¼Ã»ÓÐ

natureÉÏԭʼ¹¤×÷Òѱ»±á£¬ÎÒµÄССÒýÉ껹Ôõô¸Ä°¡
3Â¥2014-03-17 12:05:11
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

potyvirus

ľ³æ (ÕýʽдÊÖ)

¡ï
Сľ³æ: ½ð±Ò+0.5, ¸ø¸öºì°ü£¬Ð»Ð»»ØÌû
×öÁËЩСС¸Ä¶¯ºÍ´´ÐÂ........
5Â¥2014-03-17 14:06:42
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû
×î¾ßÈËÆøÈÈÌûÍÆ¼ö [²é¿´È«²¿] ×÷Õß »Ø/¿´ ×îºó·¢±í
[¿¼ÑÐ] »·¾³¹¤³Ìµ÷¼Á +8 ´ó¿Édigkids 2026-03-16 8/400 2026-03-18 09:36 by zhukairuo
[¿¼ÑÐ] ²ÄÁÏר˶306Ó¢Ò»Êý¶þ +9 z1z2z3879 2026-03-16 12/600 2026-03-18 08:53 by zhukairuo
[¿¼ÑÐ] 334Çóµ÷¼Á +3 Ö¾´æ¸ßÔ¶ÒâÔÚ»úÐ 2026-03-16 3/150 2026-03-18 08:34 by lm4875102
[¿¼ÑÐ] 085601Çóµ÷¼Á +4 Du.11 2026-03-16 4/200 2026-03-17 17:08 by ruiyingmiao
[¿¼ÑÐ] 0854¿É¿çµ÷¼Á£¬Ò»×÷Ò»ÏîºËÐÄÂÛÎÄÎåÏîרÀû£¬Ê¡¡¢¹ú¼¶Ö¤Êé40+ÊýÒ»Ó¢Ò»287 +3 СÀî0854 2026-03-16 3/150 2026-03-17 13:40 by ÈÈÇéɳĮ
[¿¼²©] 26É격 +4 °ËÑ®ËÙÀÀ 2026-03-16 4/200 2026-03-17 13:00 by ÇáËɲ»ÉÙËæ
[¿¼ÑÐ] 267Ò»Ö¾Ô¸ÄϾ©¹¤Òµ´óѧ0817»¯¹¤Çóµ÷¼Á +6 SUICHILD 2026-03-12 6/300 2026-03-17 09:24 by ÎíÉ¢ºóÏàÓölc
[¿¼ÑÐ] 333Çóµ÷¼Á +3 ÎÄ˼¿Í 2026-03-16 7/350 2026-03-16 18:21 by ÎÄ˼¿Í
[¿¼ÑÐ] 326Çóµ÷¼Á +4 ŵ±´¶û»¯Ñ§½±êéê 2026-03-15 7/350 2026-03-16 17:11 by ŵ±´¶û»¯Ñ§½±êéê
[¿¼ÑÐ] 304Çóµ÷¼Á +4 ahbd 2026-03-14 4/200 2026-03-16 16:48 by ÎҵĴ¬Îҵĺ£
[¿¼ÑÐ] ²ÄÁϹ¤³Ì327Çóµ÷¼Á +3 xiaohe12w 2026-03-11 3/150 2026-03-14 20:20 by ms629
[»ù½ðÉêÇë] ÏÖÔÚÈçºÎ»Ø±ÜÈ¥ÄêµÄijһ¸öר¼Ò£¬²»ÖªµÀÃû×Ö +3 zk200107 2026-03-12 6/300 2026-03-14 17:13 by zk200107
[¿¼ÑÐ] ¡¾0703»¯Ñ§µ÷¼Á¡¿-Ò»Ö¾Ô¸»ªÖÐʦ·¶´óѧ-Áù¼¶475 +5 Becho359 2026-03-11 5/250 2026-03-14 11:35 by ŶŶ123
[»ù½ðÉêÇë] ÓбØÒª¸ü»»É걨¿ÚÂð 20+3 fannyamoy 2026-03-11 3/150 2026-03-14 00:52 by zhanghaozhu
[¿¼ÑÐ] £Û0860£Ý321·ÖÇóµ÷¼Á£¬abÇø½Ô¿É +4 ±¦¹óÈÈ 2026-03-13 4/200 2026-03-13 22:01 by ÐÇ¿ÕÐÇÔÂ
[¿¼ÑÐ] 333Çóµ÷¼Á +3 ÇòÇò¹ÅÁ¦ 2026-03-11 3/150 2026-03-13 21:27 by JourneyLucky
[¿¼ÑÐ] 314Çóµ÷¼Á +7 ÎÞи¿É»÷µÄ¾ÞÈË 2026-03-12 7/350 2026-03-13 15:40 by JourneyLucky
[¿¼ÑÐ] ÍÁľµÚÒ»Ö¾Ô¸276Çóµ÷¼Á£¬¿ÆÑкͼ¼ÄÜÊ®·Ö·á¸»£¬ÇóÐÂÐË·½ÏòµÄµ¼Ê¦ÊÕÁô +3 ÍÁľСÌì²Å 2026-03-12 3/150 2026-03-13 15:01 by JourneyLucky
[¿¼ÑÐ] 085600²ÄÁÏÓ뻯¹¤ 309·ÖÇëÇóµ÷¼Á +7 dtdxzxx 2026-03-12 8/400 2026-03-13 14:43 by jxchenghu
[¿¼ÑÐ] 277Çóµ÷¼Á +4 anchor17 2026-03-12 4/200 2026-03-13 11:15 by °×Ò¹ÓÆ³¤
ÐÅÏ¢Ìáʾ
ÇëÌî´¦ÀíÒâ¼û