24小时热门版块排行榜

>论坛更新日志 (3904)
>虫友互识 (616)
>文献求助 (245)
>导师招生 (159)
>休闲灌水 (95)
>招聘信息布告栏 (90)
>考博 (76)
>博后之家 (67)
>论文投稿 (47)
>硕博家园 (32)
>教师之家 (27)
>考研 (24)
>晶体 (23)
>论文道贺祈福 (22)
>公派出国 (21)
>基金申请 (17)

返回列表

huomingying

银虫 (正式写手)

应助: 52 (初中生)
金币: 399.6
散金: 1270
红花: 9
帖子: 581
在线: 235小时
虫号: 2007285
注册: 2012-09-17
性别: GG
专业: 导航、制导与传感技术

[求助] 求鉴定是大修还是小修，还有中的可能！

小弟我之前中了几篇国内的EI，这是小弟第一次尝试投SCI。去年10月初投的，一直审到今年3月。第一个评审专家就是让加一段解释，两个简单的语法修改，基本算小修吧。第二个专家很认真，把我将近40个公式从头到尾推了一边，其中我确实有一些敲写错误都给我指出了；还把我参考文献下载看了一下，说参考文献应该是“original source of a work”，有两个参考文献写错了；另外也让我在文中加一些解释；修改意见写了很多很详细，但是基本是以上3类，没有对研究问题、方法和结果提出异议。大家说说这样是大修还是小修呢？这次还需要评审那么长时间么？我本想要中一篇SCI，这学期博士开题能够顺利点，不知道计划能不能达成。以下是修改意见（确实有点多）：

Reviewer #1: 5. Numerical Simulations;
It would be better if you can explain the physical meanings of the optimization result more.
The optimized state/control histories in Fig.7 is very interesting. Readers would like to question why these histories are physically　optimal. For example the orbital radius first increases from 1 to 1.05 for about 50 days then decreases to 0.8. Why wouldn't it monotonically decrease from 1 to 0.8? For other example, the zenithal angle first decreases slowly but after 150th day, it rapidly decreases to 80 deg.
Why wouldn't it keep the same change rate?
Although these histories are NLP result, the physical meaning of these behaviors are not trivial.
For the completeness of this paper, I recommend that you add explanation for them.
Abstract: the solutions of general mode and geostationary mode <of> electric sail
1. Introduction 1st paragraph: analysis the stability -> analyzed the stability
2. Dynamical Equation: It would be better if the angle alpha and beta are defined(cone and clock) in this section not in the following section.

Reviewer #2: The paper investigates displaced orbits using an electric sail. This is an interesting topic and some results are shown. However, there are several parts of this paper that are not clear to evaluate further, so I have the following comments for major revision.
General：
- This paper does not have enough fundamental explanations. Please specify the following points
1) The reason why authors selected the inertial spherical referenced frame for electric sail.
2) The reason why the transition trajectory is optimized to minimize transfer time. What does 'orbital transfer capability of electric sail' mean?
- There are some typographical errors or mathematical mistakes. Please check all equations. If there exits some mathematical mistake, the results become unreliable.
- References must be original source of a work. In addition please check if all cite numbers are correct.

Specific:
Nomenclature:
-'a_+' and subscripts '+' are confusing.
1. Introduction:
- p.2 line 6. '100kg propellant mass'. Is this not propellant mass but total spacecraft mass?
- P.2 line 10 after Fig. 1. 'The results show that the thrust force of the solar sail decays as (1/r)^2, and that of the electric sail decays as (1/r)^(7/6)'. Mengali [12] also refer Janhunen [9]. Therefore this sentence is confusing.
2. Dynamical Equations
- Eq.(2). K=cos_theta i '+' sin_theta j. Is this equation correct? If this is correct, Eq.(3) and (5) are wrong. Or K=cos_theta i '-' sin_theta j ?
- Eq.(5). 'phi'sin_theta i. typographical error. 'phi_dot'sin_theta i
- Eq.(9). There exists mathematical mistake. The third term about vector k, not '2(r_dot)(phi_dot)cos_theta', but '2r(phi_dot)(theta_dot)cos_theta'. Also, Eq. (13) has mistake.
- p.2 line 1 before Eq. (11). Is the reference [13] correct?
- Eq. (11). Please explain from what the coefficient k(kappa) is given. Is this variable value through a mission? Or specify reference about the coefficient.
3. Displaced Electric Sail Orbits
- Please check the subscripts about acceleration. 'a_+' and 'a_+d' are confusing. Eq. (11) and (12) use 'a_+', but Eq. (16) use 'a_+d'. Is this 'a_+'? Is 'a_+' of Eq.(11) acceleration of the sail on Earth's orbit? On the other hand, what does 'a_+d' of Eq.(19) and (23) mean? Is this required acceleration on Earth's orbit or displaced orbit? Is this equal to magnitude of 'a_s'?
5. Numerical Simulations
- p.6 line 10 after '5. Numerical Simulations'. This is not principle discussion. Therefore it cannot be mentioned that 'So that the electric sail is more competent than solar sail in the application of displaced orbit.' What does 'existing technology' mean? Acceleration of a solar sail is determined by total spacecraft mass and sail area mainly. I recommend comparison of, for example, payload mass fraction because that of electric sail is shown.
- Fig. 7. History of |a_s| in Eq. (11) should be shown.

回复此楼