| 查看: 2938 | 回复: 18 | ||||||
[求助]
审稿人对我只用B3LYP有意见
|
|
审稿人意见：B3LYP is a functional known to have very large exact exchange component (20%) favoring too loose electron densities and low transition energies. State-of-the-art is to at least use also a functional of the GGA class with zero exact exchange, which will give an impression of the error/spread obtainable from DFT, currently not described. 我的回答：B3LYP, as a hybrid functional parameterized to fit data primarily for main group molecules, has achieved outstanding accuracy and has been widely used in theoretical chemistry calculation. However, B3LYP is known to have very large exact exchange component (20%) favoring too loose electron densities and low transition energies. So, using the pure functional BP86 is necessary, which is a GGA class with zero exact exchange (0%). It can provide another side of the coin. So, we have also performed the geometry optimization, vibrational analysis and excited states calculation using pure functional BP86. The results have been added into the new version of manuscript. 本人纯属量化菜鸟，有个问题，请高手指点： 1、B3LYP中的20%交换相关项是什么? 2、为什么要用纯的泛函BP86来验证? |
回复此楼» 收录本帖的淘帖专辑推荐
 高斯及相关软件的使用 | 量化学习 | 审稿意见 | 计算化学 |
» 猜你喜欢
招贤纳博（已结束）
已经有29人回复
-
表征测试机构后台私聊我
已经有0人回复
-
物理化学论文润色/翻译怎么收费?
已经有293人回复
-
需要一个圆偏振光诱导化学反应，请问使用圆偏振光作为光源，应该需要哪些设备搭建
已经有0人回复
-
Coordination Chemistry Reviews
已经有1人回复
-
请问现在还有电池材料方向的博导招人吗
已经有4人回复
2楼2011-10-23 10:30:19
3楼2011-10-23 10:37:10
yongleli
木虫 (正式写手)
- 应助: 93 (初中生)
- 金币: 3769.1
- 散金: 369
- 红花: 24
- 帖子: 764
- 在线: 101.3小时
- 虫号: 303595
- 注册: 2006-12-03
- 专业: 原子和分子物理
4楼2011-10-23 10:55:08
yongleli
木虫 (正式写手)
- 应助: 93 (初中生)
- 金币: 3769.1
- 散金: 369
- 红花: 24
- 帖子: 764
- 在线: 101.3小时
- 虫号: 303595
- 注册: 2006-12-03
- 专业: 原子和分子物理
5楼2011-10-23 10:56:06
lyy880530
木虫 (正式写手)
- 应助: 0 (幼儿园)
- 金币: 2806.5
- 散金: 304
- 红花: 4
- 帖子: 967
- 在线: 442.9小时
- 虫号: 743913
- 注册: 2009-04-09
- 性别: MM
- 专业: 能源化工
|
我的审稿意见也是这个意思， it is well known that the B3LYP tends to favor high spin states over low spin states. This is due to the HF exchange energy mixture that has this intrinsic feature and it should always be properly calibrated. One way to do this would be to compare the hybrid vs pure GGA functionals and check the energy difference between the quintet and the septet states. Or by smoothly change the quantity of HF exchange and look at the energy gap. Did the authors check this ? This can be quite important because along the reaction energy path you may get “earlier” or “later” spin-crossing. 看到你的帖子了，正好想请教你一下 |
6楼2011-10-23 11:29:36
7楼2011-10-23 14:41:21
beefly
专家顾问 (职业作家)
地沟油冶炼专家
-
专家经验: +457 - QC强帖: 12
- 应助: 86 (初中生)
- 金币: 12719.4
- 散金: 27307
- 红花: 300
- 帖子: 4663
- 在线: 925.3小时
- 虫号: 408372
- 注册: 2007-06-21
- 性别: GG
- 专业: 理论和计算化学
- 管辖: 计算模拟
8楼2011-10-23 15:14:08
lihb734
铁杆木虫 (职业作家)
站在计算化学入门的门槛上
- QC强帖: 2
- 应助: 132 (高中生)
- 金币: 7495.4
- 散金: 9378
- 红花: 74
- 帖子: 3107
- 在线: 1177.3小时
- 虫号: 448403
- 注册: 2007-11-01
- 性别: GG
- 专业: 理论和计算化学
9楼2011-10-24 13:54:23
qzhaosdu
金虫 (著名写手)
- 应助: 0 (幼儿园)
- 金币: 1401.6
- 散金: 2052
- 红花: 7
- 帖子: 1969
- 在线: 263.5小时
- 虫号: 493351
- 注册: 2008-01-10
- 性别: GG
- 专业: 理论和计算化学
- 管辖: 量子化学
10楼2011-10-24 15:38:07