[交流] 修改后还有希望？ 已有6人参与

一篇文章投到elsevier的杂志，第一次投稿，编辑建议修改后重新投，修改重投，昨天收到意见 revision（major revision），见下面，不知道修改后命运如何啊！有个审稿人的意见好难回答，快被这篇文章折磨晕了！ I regret to inform you that your manuscript was not found acceptable for publication in its present form. We would be prepared, however, to reconsider the manuscript if it can be revised to meet the objections detailed in the comments appended below. The editors have set the major revision deadline at 42 days from the date of this letter. We would appreciate receiving your revised manuscript by that time. Editor's comments: This manuscript may be suitable for publication in Analytica Chimica Acta but it needs major revision before it can be reconsidered. Detailed reviewer comments are given below. The key requirements are 1.   ...2.....3....

回复此楼