24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

liuyalihd

铜虫 (小有名气)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 117.7
散金: 577
帖子: 59
在线: 8.7小时
虫号: 531310
注册: 2008-03-23
专业: 计算机体系结构

[交流] 写修改信时要把reviewer的意见原样粘上，然后一一回复吗？

1）写修改信，要把reviewer的意见一字不落的粘上，然后每个修改意见后另起一行，写我的change？这样会不会觉得很乱？

2）另外说我英文不好，我该如何回复？请给个范例呀，我英文真不好！

回复此楼

» 猜你喜欢

博士读完未来一定会好吗已经有21人回复
导师想让我从独立一作变成了共一第一已经有5人回复
到新单位后，换了新的研究方向，没有团队，持续积累2区以上论文，能申请到面上吗已经有11人回复
读博已经有4人回复
JMPT 期刊投稿流程已经有4人回复
心脉受损已经有5人回复
Springer期刊投稿求助已经有4人回复
小论文投稿已经有3人回复
Bioresource Technology期刊，第一次返修的时候被退回好几次了已经有9人回复
申请2026年博士已经有6人回复

» 本主题相关价值贴推荐，对您同样有帮助:

图谱修改已经有3人回复
中科院博士考完跟老师联系没回复，该怎么办已经有13人回复
journal of membrane science 修改稿求助已经有14人回复
急，刚投稿之后回复生成的PDF有问题，请教~~~ 已经有5人回复
怎么提高氟碳树脂粘度已经有29人回复
急求大家的意见！已经有13人回复
本科迁到西安771所了有没有人知道怎么回事不要网上复制粘贴的老帖已经有18人回复
申请reviewer 已经有5人回复
reviewer 內容說明不接受此paper ，但是主編回信要我修正後上傳! 已经有26人回复
APL securing reviewer 27天了，要不要写催稿信？已经有9人回复
投稿三个月，编辑回信reviewer换人了，这论文还有戏吗？已经有22人回复
修改意见只有一个reviewer#1，但是Review Attachments中还有一个，杂回事？已经有8人回复
论文小修，请问修改后还需要送给reviewer吗？已经有6人回复
很有趣：当Reviewer变成文章的合作者时，如何回复他的审稿意见？请高人指点，谢谢！已经有35人回复

1楼2010-09-15 16:24:15

已阅回复此楼关注TA 给TA发消息送TA红花 TA的回帖

dzckeyan

木虫 (正式写手)

应助: 1 (幼儿园)
金币: 4677.6
散金: 41
帖子: 367
在线: 223小时
虫号: 638062
注册: 2008-10-27
专业: 环境地球化学

大家帮我看看我该怎么写修改说明？

I have received the reviews for your manuscript, "****", which you submitted to ****.

Based on these reviews, your manuscript is accepted for publication pending receipt of a revised manuscript. When preparing your revised manuscript, carefully consider the attached reviewer comments, and submit a list of revisions based on the comments. Your list of responses should be uploaded as a file in addition to your revised manuscript.

Go to the link below for the Author's Instructions. If the Author's Instructions link does not work, copy and paste the link into your web browser.

Author's Instructions: ***

Submit your revised manuscript to:

***

Your username is: ***
Your password is: ****

Click "Author Login" to submit your revision.

I look forward to receiving your revised manuscript.

Best regards,

***
Editor-in-Chief
***

COMMENTS FOR THE AUTHOR:

You must have a native English speaker correct the grammar and syntax.

Rewrite the abstract using numbers to tell your story.

Reformat this ms. using the instructions on this website.

Delete subheadings.

EDITORIAL REQUIREMENTS

Yes  No  N/A

(x)    ()    ()  Manuscript Length is Appropriate
(x)    ()    ()  Manuscript Prepared According to Instructions
()    (x)    ()       Clearly written with proper English grammar and syntax.
()    (x)    ()       Introductory paragraphs are concise and  appropriate
(x)    ()    ()  References cited to current studies in introduction.
(x)    ()    ()       There is a clear purpose & hypothesis for the study.
(x)    ()    ()       Sampling is described.
(x)    ()    ()       Methods & Materials section is detailed so that the study could be repeated.
(x)    ()    ()       Analytical methods are described or provided by readily available reference(s).
()    (x)    ()       Limits of detection are reported.
()    (x)    ()       Fortified sample recoveries are reported.
()    ()    (x)       Statistics are appropriate and are referenced in the Materials & Methods section.
(x)    ()    ()       Data are compared to other studies.
()    (x)    ()       References are current and appropriate
(x)    ()    ()  Significance of findings are described.

TECHNICAL MERIT

Check one rank in each category
   1 = poor, 5 = excellent

1 2 3 4 5
()  ()  ()  (x)  ()  Clarity
()  ()  ()  ()  (x)  Technical Quality
()  ()  ()  (x)  ()  Originality
()  ()  ()  ()  (x)  Novelty.
()  ()  ()  ()  (x)  Data interpretation is appropriate.
()  ()  ()  (x)  ()  Scientific value

SIGNIFICANCE
() None
() Local
(x) National
() Regional
() Global
The first three paragraphs in Materials and Methods should be in the Introduction which should be edited for length.
Manuscript exceeds the length of 8 pages as stated in the Instructions to Authors, which see.
References should be limited to one page with older references cited to Reviews.

这样写吗？
Comment:
You must have a native English speaker correct the grammar and syntax.
Response: Yes. We invited several native English speakers to check and revise the language errors.  And we asked some professors who are skilled authors to revised the mannuscript.

Comment (continued):
Rewrite the abstract using numbers to tell your story.
Response: Yes. The abstract was rewrited using numbers.

Comment (continued):
Reformat this ms. using the instructions on this website.
Response: Yes. The revised manuscript was reformated following the Author's Instructions.

Comment (continued):
Delete subheadings.
Response: Yes. The subheadings were deleted.

Editoral requirements
Yes  No  N/A
() (x) () Introductory paragraphs are concise and  appropriate
() (x) () Limits of detection are reported.
() (x) () Fortified sample recoveries are reported.
() () (x) Statistics are appropriate and are referenced in the Materials & Methods section.
() (x) () References are current and appropriate
Response: We reorganized and condensed introductory paragraphs.
Limits of detection are added and reported now.
Fortified sample recoveries are reported now.
Statistics are appropriate and are referenced now.
Latest references are added and older ones cited to reviews.

Other comments and suggestions:
The first three paragraphs in Materials and Methods should be in the Introduction which should be edited for length.
Response: Yes. We did it follows the comment and suggestion.

Manuscript exceeds the length of 8 pages as stated in the Instructions to Authors, which see.
Response: Yes. The revised manuscript pages count is 8 now.

References should be limited to one page with older references cited to Reviews.
Response: Latest references are added and older ones cited to reviews. And they are limited to one page now.