24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

dzckeyan

木虫 (正式写手)

应助: 1 (幼儿园)
金币: 4677.6
散金: 41
帖子: 367
在线: 223小时
虫号: 638062
注册: 2008-10-27
专业: 环境地球化学

[交流] 敬请高手同仁分析一下审稿意见已有2人参与

6月3号投稿，6月8号以后的状态都是with associate editor-under review，9月5号通过投稿系统send-email催问了一下，回复内容如下：
Thank you for inquiring about the status of your manuscript.

After checking the records, I can confirm that currently, your paper ****, is still with the Associate Editor and reviewers are yet to be invited.  The editor handling your paper will contact you as soon as the peer review process has been completed.

Meanwhile, I would like to inform you that although the journal aims to communicate decisions to authors as soon as possible, the actual time lag for a submission varies due to a number of factors, including the responsiveness and availability of the reviewers.

Should you have further concerns, please feel free to notify me.
With kind regards,

Springer
JEO Assistant

9月9号投稿状态变成了Submissions Needing Revision，Minor Revision，收到的修改邮件如下，是不是初稿没有送外审啊？通常情况下不是会有3-4个审稿人的具体审稿意见吗？怎么这篇稿子没有这样的具体修改意见呢？修改稿提交后是不是才送外审啊？请高手帮忙分析一下，谢谢

I have received the reviews for your manuscript, "****", which you submitted to ****.

Based on these reviews, your manuscript is accepted for publication pending receipt of a revised manuscript. When preparing your revised manuscript, carefully consider the attached reviewer comments, and submit a list of revisions based on the comments. Your list of responses should be uploaded as a file in addition to your revised manuscript.

Go to the link below for the Author's Instructions. If the Author's Instructions link does not work, copy and paste the link into your web browser.

Author's Instructions: ***

Submit your revised manuscript to:

***

Your username is: ***
Your password is: ****

Click "Author Login" to submit your revision.

I look forward to receiving your revised manuscript.

Best regards,

***
Editor-in-Chief
***

COMMENTS FOR THE AUTHOR:

You must have a native English speaker correct the grammar and syntax.

Rewrite the abstract using numbers to tell your story.

Reformat this ms. using the instructions on this website.

Delete subheadings.

EDITORIAL REQUIREMENTS

Yes  No  N/A

(x)    ()    ()  Manuscript Length is Appropriate
(x)    ()    ()  Manuscript Prepared According to Instructions
()    (x)    () Clearly written with proper English grammar and syntax.
()    (x)    () Introductory paragraphs are concise and  appropriate
(x)    ()    ()  References cited to current studies in introduction.
(x)    ()    () There is a clear purpose & hypothesis for the study.
(x)    ()    () Sampling is described.
(x)    ()    () Methods & Materials section is detailed so that the study could be repeated.
(x)    ()    () Analytical methods are described or provided by readily available reference(s).
()    (x)    () Limits of detection are reported.
()    (x)    () Fortified sample recoveries are reported.
()    ()    (x) Statistics are appropriate and are referenced in the Materials & Methods section.
(x)    ()    () Data are compared to other studies.
()    (x)    () References are current and appropriate
(x)    ()    ()  Significance of findings are described.

TECHNICAL MERIT

Check one rank in each category
   1 = poor, 5 = excellent

1 2 3 4 5
()  ()  ()  (x)  ()  Clarity
()  ()  ()  ()  (x)  Technical Quality
()  ()  ()  (x)  ()  Originality
()  ()  ()  ()  (x)  Novelty.
()  ()  ()  ()  (x)  Data interpretation is appropriate.
()  ()  ()  (x)  ()  Scientific value

SIGNIFICANCE
() None
() Local
(x) National
() Regional
() Global
The first three paragraphs in Materials and Methods should be in the Introduction which should be edited for length.
Manuscript exceeds the length of 8 pages as stated in the Instructions to Authors, which see.
References should be limited to one page with older references cited to Reviews.

回复此楼