[交流] jacs修改中稿机率大吗？---[color=Red]已中稿[/color] 已有26人参与

刚刚上网看了下，文章已经接收，大修=变小修=最后接受。呵呵！！ 多谢虫友们的帮助 最近投了一篇美国化学会志（JACS），两个审稿人，一个说建议发表在别的期刊，另一个建议小修后发表，最后编辑要求我们修改。不知道这种情况中稿的机率大吗？编辑的意见大致如下： >Thank you for submitting your manuscript for publication in the Journal of the American Chemical Society.  It has been examined by expert reviewers who have concluded that the work is of potential interest to the readership of JACS; however, the reviewers raise cogent issues that need proper attention.  Please see the enclosed comments of the reviewers for details regarding the requested changes and/or additions.  I am willing to consider a suitably-revised manuscript that properly addresses the concerns of the reviewers. > >We ask that you submit your revision within 60 days. > >Your manuscript is likely to go back to the present reviewers and possibly to one or more additional new reviewer(s) for further input and advice before any final decision on publication is made.  To help me expedite processing, explicitly address the questions raised by the Editor and reviewers and clearly point out the changes made in the manuscript.  Provide this information in the "Response to Decision Letter" text box when you submit the revised manuscript.  Alternatively, you may attach a file containing your detailed responses, including explanations for disagreeing with any of the suggestions that you have chosen not to follow.  Please annotate a copy of the manuscript to show revisions and track changes for the benefit of the reviewers.  This marked manuscript should be uploaded electronically in the File Upload section as "Supporting Information for Review Only". [ Last edited by dqchen on 2010-6-30 at 05:48 ]

回复此楼