| 查看: 983 | 回复: 13 | |||
| 当前主题已经存档。 | |||
| 当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖 | |||
[交流]
Macromolecules被拒，是否可补全数据再投？
|
|||
|
2月8号投ma，昨天回来结果。一个审稿人拒，一个审稿人说小修。 想请教下，将第一个审稿人说的不足的地方补一下，把数据表证得漂亮点，该改的地方改一下，是否可以再投ma? 2个审稿人的意见如下： Reviewer(s)' Comments to Author: > Reviewer: 1 > > Recommendation: Publish as is, or with minor revisions as > noted. > > Comments: > The paper is generally interesting. I do not have any > serious issues. It should be published with minor > changes. Some typographical errors need to be > corrected. For example, on page 6 (line 48) > ‘leaving’ needs to be changed to ‘living’. > Other queries are as follows: > 1) In section… “Synthesis of > starch-based xanthate agent – Authors state that the > “reaction mixture was allowed to react for 24 > hrs.” It is not clear if that was at 100C or at room > temperature? > It is not clear how the films were prepared for the contact > angle. Were they conditioned at ASTM conditions or > were they bone dry? The contact angle will certainly > be dependent on the condition of the films. > > > Additional Questions: > Do these findings represent a significant advance in the > polymer field?: Yes > > Please rate the overall quality and clarity of the > manuscript: Good > > Are the conclusions adequately supported by the data?: Yes > > Reviewer: 2 > > Recommendation: Do not publish. > Comments: > The manuscript by Lu et al on the synthesis of starch > derivatives is potentially very interesting. However, I feel > that it has too many analytical gaps to be suitable for > synthesis in Macromolecules. > The weak point of the manuscript is the analysis of the > polymer prepared. > The authors only showed the increase of the molecular > weight in Figure 4, but this is not sufficient to prove the > livingness of the system. The high PDIs suggest already that > the polymerization is not perfect. The GPC curves should be > displayed to show the shape (and potential formation of high > molecular weight products). In addition, it is common > procedure to cleave the arms from the backbone to confirm > that the molecular weight of the arm is close to the > theoretical value. > Other comments: > Scheme 1: The authors should consider that two products are > formed when adding on to the double bond. I don’t think it > has an effect on the polymerization though. > Figure 2: There is a CH2 group missing in the structure of > the NMR shown. The missing group is also not assigned > I recommend showing the NMR of the hydrolyzed product to > confirm that all the groups have been hydrolyzed. FT-IR > analysis is only complementary > Unfortunately, I cannot recommend publication this time, > but I recommend the authors to spend more time on further > investigations. This could be potentially nice work 第二个审稿人最后一句话是否可以理解为如果再补全数据，把数据做更漂亮可以再投ma试试？ 希望有经验的虫友给些建议，万分感谢。 PS: 编辑的意见是拒绝.编辑采纳了第二个审稿人的意见. [ Last edited by snailove on 2010-3-16 at 23:09 ] |
回复此楼» 猜你喜欢
求调剂
已经有3人回复
-
一志愿北京化工大学，初试成绩350求调剂
已经有14人回复
-
复试调剂
已经有4人回复
-
323分（计算机视觉和大模型项目）能直接上手
已经有3人回复
-
311分 22408 求调剂
已经有3人回复
-
320分人工智能调剂
已经有7人回复
-
一志愿郑大0705求调剂
已经有4人回复
-
0703化学
已经有10人回复
-
301求调剂
已经有10人回复
-
306分材料与化工求调剂
已经有6人回复
9楼2010-03-16 22:18:00
2楼2010-03-16 13:08:12
sunke
至尊木虫 (知名作家)
- 应助: 172 (高中生)
- 贵宾: 0.417
- 金币: 15024.8
- 散金: 687
- 红花: 7
- 沙发: 8
- 帖子: 8688
- 在线: 535.1小时
- 虫号: 461515
- 注册: 2007-11-18
- 性别: GG
- 专业: 无机非金属类高温超导与磁
3楼2010-03-16 13:26:02
sunke
至尊木虫 (知名作家)
- 应助: 172 (高中生)
- 贵宾: 0.417
- 金币: 15024.8
- 散金: 687
- 红花: 7
- 沙发: 8
- 帖子: 8688
- 在线: 535.1小时
- 虫号: 461515
- 注册: 2007-11-18
- 性别: GG
- 专业: 无机非金属类高温超导与磁
4楼2010-03-16 13:26:32
