24小时热门版块排行榜    

Znn3bq.jpeg
查看: 814  |  回复: 6
当前主题已经存档。

wolfzhong

木虫 (正式写手)

[交流] 一篇JPC文章审稿人的意见

????????????????
?????????????????????С??2?????
???????????????????
Reviewer: 2

Recommendation: This paper is not recommended because the material is not
appropriate for the Journal of Physical Chemistry.

Comments:
In this work the authors present a very thorough survey of the energies
and structures of possible di- and tri-nuclear Cr-carbonyl complexes using
standard DFT methods. The technical execution is in good order and the
presentation is also solidly done. I am puzzled, however, why this
material is being sent to J. of Phys. Chem. - I can't really see a lot of
physical chemists enjoying this material. It seems to me that this work
should be more interesting to the organometallic community.
Organometallics or the J. of Organometallic Chem. would be a much better
forum for this work.

I also urge the authors to consider rewriting the paper to make it a
little more exciting.
In the current form, each structure and its energy
is being presented in a very linear fashion. I do see the value of having
such an analysis of the different bonding and structure patterns for some
researchers, but I doubt that this work will be able to excite anyone in
its current form. This looks like a very mundane and standard application
of DFT that anyone with a laptop can do within a week.


????????????????????????
We have now received two reviews of your manuscript, which you will find
below.  As you will see, one reviewer indicates that only minor revisions
are needed, while the other recommends against publication.  Both
reviewers suggest revisions be made to your manuscript.  The primary
criticism of reviewer 2 is a lack of physical insights gleaned from the
studies.

The criteria for publication of computational papers are that they must
satisfy at least one of the following criteria:

-         provide significant new physical insight into an experimentally
relevant system or process

-         present a new theoretical or computational methodology of
general interest

Based on this, I cannot accept the manuscript in its present form, but if
you believe it can be revised to address reviewer 2â?™s concerns, I would
consider the revised form of the manuscript.


????????????????
1.????????????JPC??????JPC?????????????????????????????????????л?????????????????????????????????????????????
2. ??????????????????????????????????????Щ???鰡
3. ????????????????????????????2??????? ???????????????????????????????????????????????ok???

??δ????????????????????????Щ???лл??
回复此楼
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

匿名

用户注销 (正式写手)

★ ★ ★
wolfzhong(金币+3,VIP+0):我论文里面就有2个模块是关于成键的物理认识及其势能面的东西啊,还要加? 1-9 13:42
本帖仅楼主可见
2楼2010-01-09 13:27:23
已阅   申请SEPI   回复此楼   编辑   查看我的主页

匿名

用户注销 (正式写手)


wolfzhong(金币+1,VIP+0):谢谢提醒哦,这边网络有问题,能取消吗? 1-9 13:43
本帖仅楼主可见
3楼2010-01-09 13:31:26
已阅   申请SEPI   回复此楼   编辑   查看我的主页

wolfzhong

木虫 (正式写手)

up

谢谢后面的同志的意见
4楼2010-01-09 14:07:53
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

jing15209791

金虫 (正式写手)


wolfzhong(金币+1,VIP+0): 1-9 14:20
好好修改吧,祝福祝福
5楼2010-01-09 14:08:39
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

chemkun

银虫 (正式写手)


wolfzhong(金币+1,VIP+0): 1-9 18:58
好好修改吧,估计问题不大,真诚和努力打动审稿人
生为化学人,死亦化学鬼
6楼2010-01-09 16:40:17
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

pepperp

至尊木虫 (文坛精英)


wolfzhong(金币+1,VIP+0): 1-9 18:58
建议改投,这样的意见很难修改的~
7楼2010-01-09 16:51:55
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖
相关版块跳转 我要订阅楼主 wolfzhong 的主题更新
普通表情 高级回复 (可上传附件)
最具人气热帖推荐 [查看全部] 作者 回/看 最后发表
[考研] 材料工程302分求调剂 +18 zyx上岸! 2026-04-04 18/900 2026-04-10 10:07 by 314126402
[考研] 青岛科技大学材料学院,环境学院调剂补录4月10日以前都可以 +3 1青科大。 2026-04-09 5/250 2026-04-10 09:58 by 翩翩一书生
[考研] 080100力学316求调剂 +7 L_Hairui 2026-04-07 7/350 2026-04-10 09:45 by vgtyfty
[考研] 求调剂 +13 MAX怅惘 2026-04-09 14/700 2026-04-10 09:14 by Delta2012
[考研] 材料与化工371求调剂 +17 陪琳看海 2026-04-04 18/900 2026-04-10 07:51 by 314126402
[考研] 一志愿211电子信息347求调剂 +3 554916 2026-04-03 4/200 2026-04-09 22:24 by 554916
[考研] 初试分332,一志愿报考西北工业大学, +11 故人?? 2026-04-09 11/550 2026-04-09 21:54 by JineShine
[考研] 本科211 工科085400 280分求调剂 可跨专业 +3 LZH(等待调剂中 2026-04-09 3/150 2026-04-09 21:29 by wutongshun
[考研] 314求调剂 +16 xhhdjdjsjks 2026-04-09 17/850 2026-04-09 18:26 by 喝醉酒N
[考研] 280求调剂 +5 兮兮夜夜 2026-04-09 8/400 2026-04-09 11:15 by 兮兮夜夜
[考研] 一志愿0807 数一英一 313 有没有二轮调剂 +11 emokidd 2026-04-08 12/600 2026-04-09 09:24 by wyf236
[考研] 材料调剂 +14 一样YWY 2026-04-06 14/700 2026-04-08 23:00 by 猪会飞
[考研] 生物学学硕,初试351分,求调剂 +4 …~、王…~ 2026-04-08 5/250 2026-04-08 21:49 by limeifeng
[考研] 318求调剂 +13 ykyhsa 2026-04-05 15/750 2026-04-08 21:37 by wj165256
[考研] 275 求调剂 +8 Lei812514 2026-04-07 8/400 2026-04-08 12:46 by chemisry
[考研] 085602调剂 初试总分335 +3 19123253302 2026-04-06 3/150 2026-04-07 18:00 by jp9609
[考研] 085600,320分求调剂 +16 大馋小子 2026-04-04 17/850 2026-04-06 07:58 by MOF_Catal
[考研] 数一英一274机械调剂 +5 星陨流霞 2026-04-04 6/300 2026-04-05 11:38 by arrow8852
[考研] 085400电子信息319求调剂(接受跨专业调剂) +5 星星不眨眼喽 2026-04-03 6/300 2026-04-04 21:50 by hemengdong
[考研] 268求调剂 +8 你好tg 2026-04-03 9/450 2026-04-04 05:08 by gswylq
信息提示
请填处理意见