| 查看: 1055 | 回复: 22 | |||
| 当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖 | |||
[交流]
审稿意见回来后，如何处理不合理的返修意见？
|
|||
|
我之前投了运筹优化领域的一个期刊ejor，第一轮审稿意见回来后，有三个专家，我按照他们的意见做了相应的修改并提交了回去，现在结果又回来了，第二和三个审稿人的意见是可以接收了。但是第一个审稿人reviewer 1又提出了两个意见，这两个意见我认为是不能改的，我个人认为是reviewer 1没正确理解文章所做出的不合理意见。然后主编看到这种情况，就有了以下的决定。 主编： As you can see from the reports enclosed, the referees hold conflicting views on your paper. In these circumstances, it has been decided that your paper should be reconsidered for publication in the EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF OPERATIONAL RESEARCH if you will revise it to meet the enclosed referees' comments. (You may wish to argue that some comments are invalid). The most critical comments from Reviewer #1 made me doubt whether I should reconsider your paper, so I need convincing arguments from you and a thorough revision to counterbalance the critical comments. When resubmitting the revised paper, please provide your answers to the referees, separately for each referee. Please also ensure that you have cited recent and relevant publications in EJOR and other OR journals. I am most grateful for your interest and hope that you will not be deterred from resubmitting this paper in the very near future. You are advised to revise and resubmit your manuscript by the Mar 09, 2026. After this time the review process of this submission will be terminated, by withdrawing your paper from the Editorial Manager, and the revised paper will have to be submitted as a new submission. Reviewer #2: All my comments have been suitably addressed. I recommend that this paper be accepted in its present version. I congratulate the authors on a very interesting paper with a solid contribution. Reviewer #3: Thank you for your careful and meticulous revision. In this revision, I find that the manuscript has fully responded to the reviewer comments from the first round. The writing and flow has been substantially improved, and the motivations, contributions, literature review, and conclusions were carefully revised. The parameter settings for the case studies have also been sufficiently justified, and I appreciate the additional figures and plots to help the audience understand the results. The quality of the article has been substantially improved after addressing all the comments from the reviewers. I have no remaining requests for revision, and I appreciate your thorough and professional response. Good luck with your future research. Reviewer #1: Thanks for the efforts that the authors have put into revising the manuscript. However, I feel that my earlier concerns have not been fully addressed. And in my view, the current version has not yet reached the standard required for publication in EJOR. Below, I outline the major points that still need attention. 意见1：。。。。。。 意见2：。。。。。。意见1和2我就不详细列出来了，因为涉及具体的文章内容。 Overall, I like the method proposed by the authors and I can see the value, however, I find that both the depth of analysis and the clarity of presentation still require substantial improvement. 现在我的可选行动方案是： (1) 我不会再修改了，但是给主编发个邮件，解释Reviewer #1的两个个人认为不合理的意见，然后改投另一个期刊。 (2) 我不可能再大修了，但会做一些句子连贯上的小修，然后在Response letter写出个人认为的修改意见的不合理之处，然后再重新提交ejor，我估计会不被接受，所以这时候是不是系统上只有这一次新的submission的拒绝记录(如果不被接受)？因为之前的submission和Reviewer2和3的意见都被删除了？ 如果我采取方案2，然后被拒绝后再去投其它omaga一类的期刊会不会有什么影响？ 谢谢~ |
回复此楼» 猜你喜欢
301求调剂
已经有10人回复
-
调剂
已经有5人回复
-
材料调剂
已经有15人回复
-
288求调剂085600材料与化工
已经有13人回复
-
调剂的同学，走过路过，不要错过
已经有13人回复
-
中科大材料299求调剂
已经有15人回复
-
0701-322 求调剂
已经有4人回复
-
0703求调剂
已经有7人回复
-
理学287分求调剂
已经有3人回复
-
A区一本交叉课题组，低分调剂，招收机械电子信息通信等交叉方向
已经有55人回复
» 抢金币啦！回帖就可以得到:
-
化学/材料研究方向湖北省级实验室招收硕士研究生
+1/149
-
2026级博士招生｜苏州国家实验室 —上海交通大学联合培养（授上交学位）
+2/84
-
北京信息科技大学智能机器人技术方向，联合清华培养硕生、博生，并长期招博士后
+1/80
-
高校教师想跳槽
+1/74
-
宁夏大学青年长江学者团队招收2026级有机化学方向审核制博士生
+2/52
-
广东石油化工学院刘诗咏教授团队化学化工、材料科学等方向尚有调剂名额
+1/34
-
【博士招生】江西理工大学，南昌大学招收博士研究生
+1/33
-
诚征女友 #西安
+1/29
-
【招生启事】大连理工大学工程力学系研究生招生
+1/18
-
深圳大学机电与控制工程学院诚招先进制造、激光加工、增材制造、塑性成形等领域博士后
+1/16
-
【碳足迹与碳中和战略】招收硕士、博士、博士后、科研助理
+1/11
-
海南大学化学院—功能分子器件团队2026博士/研究助理招生+博士后招聘
+1/7
-
0858电气专硕364求调剂
+1/5
-
温州大学王娟课题组招收2026年博士生
+1/5
-
08600工科311求调剂
+1/4
-
欢迎报考中山大学课题组，提供2026级硕士研究生名额
+1/4
-
湖南大学材料院陶益杰老师招收2026年秋季入学博士生一名-超材料方向
+1/4
-
河南大学张琳教授招收电化学方向博士研究生
+1/3
-
温州大学2026年招生（化学、材料）
+1/3
-
知名外资仪器厂家急招Application Scientist-成都
+1/1
送红花一朵 22楼2025-09-14 14:20:51
3楼2025-09-13 18:21:30
9楼2025-09-13 19:47:59
简单回复
tzynew2楼
2025-09-13 18:16
回复
BayesInter(金币+1): 谢谢参与
o 发自小木虫手机客户端
zusn6楼
2025-09-13 18:48
回复
没有感觉的鱼12楼
2025-09-13 20:57
回复
BayesInter(金币+1): 谢谢参与
。 发自小木虫IOS客户端
我才是肖牧冲7楼
2025-09-13 19:18
回复
BayesInter(金币+1): 谢谢参与
。 发自小木虫手机客户端
2025-09-13 18:25
回复
elainzaizai10楼
2025-09-13 19:54
回复
ygxzxd14楼
2025-09-13 21:27
回复
BayesInter(金币+1): 谢谢参与
?? 发自小木虫IOS客户端
明天会更好12313楼
2025-09-13 21:05
回复
BayesInter(金币+1): 谢谢参与
。 发自小木虫手机客户端
