24小时热门版块排行榜    

北京石油化工学院2026年研究生招生接收调剂公告
查看: 3387  |  回复: 9
【悬赏金币】回答本帖问题,作者风过无影2012将赠送您 15 个金币
当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖,点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

风过无影2012

金虫 (小有名气)

[求助] Macromolecules被拒,申诉有意义吗? 已有1人参与

如题,6.11投稿,7.19被拒,两个审稿人,一个小修,一个拒稿(没有明确理由),具体如下:
Reviewer: 1

Recommendation: Reconsider after major revisions.

Comments:
This manuscript reports new epoxy (EP)-based molecular composites with sulfonated aromatic polyamides,poly(p-sulfophenylene terephthalamide) (sPPTA) and poly(benzidine-2,2'-disulfonic acid terephthamide) (PBDT), as the reinforcement, which disperse uniformly in epoxy, but do not show liquid crystalline structure. It is very interesting and the paper is well designed. The mechanical properties is significantly enhanced. However, before acceptance, minor revisions are needed.
1. Fig. 1. the legend is lost.
2. NMR is suggested to prove the reaction in the scheme 1,
3. The mechanical performances decreased when the sPPTA and the PBDT were more than 6%. Please explain the reason.
4. As the properties were decreasd when the the sPPTA and the PBDT were more than 6%, please give the SEM figure to explain this phenomenon.
5. The following paper can be referred to support your study;1) Composites Part B: Engineering, 2017, 114: 111-120.


Additional Questions:
Do these findings represent a significant advance in the polymer field?: Yes

Please rate the overall quality and clarity of the manuscript: Good

Are the conclusions adequately supported by the data?: Yes

Is the Supporting Information, if included, technically sound and sufficient to support the findings of the manuscript?: Yes

Would you like to bring this manuscript to the attention of the Editor as a particularly newsworthy or noteworthy manuscript?: Yes


Reviewer: 2

Recommendation: Do not publish. This manuscript is incremental in the field, and offers little if any value to the Macromolecules community

Comments:
Please consider another journal for your manuscript

Additional Questions:
Do these findings represent a significant advance in the polymer field?: No

Please rate the overall quality and clarity of the manuscript: Fair

Are the conclusions adequately supported by the data?: In part

Is the Supporting Information, if included, technically sound and sufficient to support the findings of the manuscript?: No

Would you like to bring this manuscript to the attention of the Editor as a particularly newsworthy or noteworthy manuscript?: No

考虑是申诉还是转投,希望有经验的朋友能给予一些意见,谢谢啦,临近申请季时间也比较紧,挺焦虑的。
回复此楼

» 猜你喜欢

已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

匿名

本帖仅楼主可见
3楼2018-07-22 21:03:03
已阅   申请SEPI   回复此楼   编辑   查看我的主页
查看全部 10 个回答

yifeng11

至尊木虫 (知名作家)

感觉第二个审稿评论和第一个审稿人完全相反

发自小木虫Android客户端
2楼2018-07-22 20:54:30
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

匿名

本帖仅楼主可见
4楼2018-07-22 21:08:03
已阅   申请SEPI   回复此楼   编辑   查看我的主页

匿名

本帖仅楼主可见
5楼2018-07-22 21:08:20
已阅   申请SEPI   回复此楼   编辑   查看我的主页
不应助 确定回帖应助 (注意:应助才可能被奖励,但不允许灌水,必须填写15个字符以上)
最具人气热帖推荐 [查看全部] 作者 回/看 最后发表
[考研] 323分(计算机视觉和大模型项目)能直接上手 +3 chaoxiicy 2026-04-01 3/150 2026-04-05 00:50 by chongya
[考研] 材料工程085601数二英一335求调剂 +6 双马尾痞老板2 2026-03-31 6/300 2026-04-04 22:29 by hemengdong
[考研] 272求调剂 +4 松柏常青5 2026-04-03 4/200 2026-04-04 17:03 by babysonlkd
[考研] 085600,320分求调剂 +14 大馋小子 2026-04-04 15/750 2026-04-04 16:27 by 无际的草原
[考研] 求调剂 +3 wos666 2026-04-03 3/150 2026-04-04 05:16 by gswylq
[考研] 311求调剂 +20 zchqwer 2026-04-01 22/1100 2026-04-03 22:09 by lglzsd
[考研] 070300一志愿211,312分求调剂院校 +16 小黄鸭宝 2026-03-30 16/800 2026-04-03 19:53 by lijunpoly
[考研] 338求调剂 +4 zzz,,r 2026-04-03 4/200 2026-04-03 16:39 by lijunpoly
[考研] 315分 085602 求调剂 +15 26考研上岸版26 2026-04-02 15/750 2026-04-03 12:45 by xingguangj
[考研] 土木水利328分求调剂 +6 疾风知劲草666 2026-04-02 6/300 2026-04-03 11:38 by znian
[考研] 071000生物学调剂 +8 知昭蔓 2026-04-02 8/400 2026-04-03 10:36 by macy2011
[考研] 303求调剂 +3 一色清羽 2026-04-02 4/200 2026-04-03 10:22 by 蓝云思雨
[考研] 260求调剂 +3 朱芷琳 2026-04-02 3/150 2026-04-03 08:44 by yulian1987
[考研] 一志愿武汉理工0856,初试334 +3 26考研材料 2026-04-02 3/150 2026-04-02 21:22 by dongzh2009
[考研] 26考研调剂 +4 Wnz.20030617 2026-04-01 5/250 2026-04-02 16:11 by 1939136013狗壮
[考研] 08开头看过来!!! +4 wwwwffffff 2026-03-31 6/300 2026-04-02 11:42 by 均值回归
[考研] 0805求调剂 +8 是水分 2026-03-31 8/400 2026-04-02 10:46 by guanxin1001
[考研] 377求调剂 +3 RASKIN 2026-04-02 3/150 2026-04-02 09:45 by zzchen2000
[考研] 考研材料工程351分调剂 +5 整个好的 2026-03-31 5/250 2026-04-01 09:36 by topgun2009
[考研] 材料工程专硕求调剂 +10 hyl3153942 2026-03-29 10/500 2026-03-31 16:31 by hypershenger
信息提示
请填处理意见