| 查看: 4102 | 回复: 24 | |||
[交流]
拒稿，重投？
|
|||
|
大修后拒稿，一审，一正一负 系统上显示reject，  但是编辑信里这么写的： Dear Mr. XXX XXX, Reviewers' comments on your work have now been received. You will see that they are advising against publication of your work. Therefore I must reject it. For your guidance, I append the reviewers' comments below. You can improve the work based on the reviewers' reports and submit your improved work as a new submission. The comments made by the reviewers should be better taken of. Thank you for giving us the opportunity to consider your work. Yours sincerely, XXXXXXX Reviewer #3: The manuscript performs an experimental study on XXXXXXXXXXXX. The authors developed a XXXXXX model and tried to explain the oscillations showed in XXXXXXX. Besides those comments raised by other reviewers, I think, the authors need to clarify the major issues listed below: (1) The biggest problem for this work may be the organization of the paper. Clearly, there are both experimental results and theoretical analysis in the presents. That is, two approaches are used. But just when we look at the titles of the sections for the parts of results and discussion, it is difficult to tell the results from experiments or from the stratified model. The authors are encouraged to rework and reorganized the part of results and discussion to make it clear. (2) There is a feeling that the experimental measurements of the mean bed porosity lose some "connection" with the results predicted by the theoretical stratified model. This can be seen from the comparison of XX and XX. As clearly shown in XXX, the XXXXX fluctuates in a small amplitude when D/d>2.5. But in Fig. 7(a), the authors only provide the predicted smooth values of mean porosity (by the theoretical stratified model) in small range of XXXX, although one may find fluctuating results for other variables of XXX at XXXXX. What about the predicted XXXXXXXX (by the theoretical XXXXX model) at higher XXXXXXX? So I would suggest the authors perform a direct comparison of the measured and predicted XXXXXXXX, to demonstrate if the measurements and predictions could really fluctuate in a similar pace or a pattern showing a correlation. (3) It seems there are data repeatedly presenting for the parameter XXXXX in Fig. 7(b), 8(b) and 9, although they are shown in different range of D/d. (4) Two same symbols of 'D' in Table 2. Which one is for cylinder column diameter and which one for particle diameter？ There may be some typos here. Based on the above comments, I can NOT recommend the acceptance of the present paper for publication in this journal. 这样的意见算不算reject&resubmit？重投需要注意哪些问题呢？ |
回复此楼» 猜你喜欢
自荐读博
已经有9人回复
-
投稿Elsevier的杂志（返修），总是在选择OA和subscription界面被踢皮球
已经有8人回复
-
自然科学基金委宣布启动申请书“瘦身提质”行动
已经有4人回复
-
求个博导看看
已经有18人回复
» 抢金币啦！回帖就可以得到:
-
上海交通大学医学院王戈林课题组招聘博士后和助理研究员
+1/273
-
诚征另一半
+1/159
-
限广州，征女友
+2/104
-
中科院长春光机所 招收计算材料学博士/硕士研究生（含机器学习辅助材料设计方向）
+1/80
-
成都理工大学全国重点实验室公开诚聘绿色有机合成方向联培生及科研助理
+1/79
-
中国科学院大连化学物理研究所DNL0902研究组招聘博士后和职工
+1/36
-
暨南大学理工学院 光子技术研究院段宣明团队申请制读博招生
+1/27
-
盐湖所镁基储氢材料课题组招聘
+1/26
-
南京工业大学招收2026年全日制学术博士（供热、供燃气通风与空调）
+1/13
-
国家级人才课题组招收生物学相关专业2026年入学博士生
+1/12
-
博士/硕士招生
+1/11
-
复旦大学聂志鸿团队招聘聚电解质方向博士后和科研助理
+1/10
-
从业之感悟
+2/8
-
国家级人才课题组招收2026年入学博士
+1/7
-
哈尔滨工业大学招收硕士研究生（欢迎环境、市政、生物、化学、农业等专业，长期有效）
+1/7
-
代算！材料学理论计算
+1/6
-
211 院校 化学工程与技术 双一流学科 学术型博士研究生 尚有名额
+1/4
-
中国矿业大学黄赳课题组联合中国科学院南京土壤研究所朱晓芳研究员诚聘博士后
+1/3
-
湖南大学机械与运载工程学院赵岩副教授课题组招生2026级普通博士生1名
+1/2
-
2026年国家级海外人才（启明计划&火炬计划）申报政策常见问题及答疑
+1/1
★ ★
郭梓歌(金币+1): 谢谢参与
郭梓歌(liouzhan654代发): 金币+1, 感谢交流 2017-08-10 08:12:10
郭梓歌(金币+1): 谢谢参与
郭梓歌(liouzhan654代发): 金币+1, 感谢交流 2017-08-10 08:12:10
|
按照reviewer的意见认真修改之后再投就可以了 发自小木虫IOS客户端 |
6楼2017-08-09 21:12:45
★
小木虫: 金币+0.5, 给个红包，谢谢回帖
小木虫: 金币+0.5, 给个红包，谢谢回帖
|
大概意思就是论文写得有点乱，人家审稿人觉得调理不清晰吧？感觉审稿人没有否定你的模型和你的工作，你按他说的好好改改再重新投这个期刊呗？ 发自小木虫IOS客户端 |
24楼2018-10-09 00:15:13
2楼2017-08-09 21:07:49
5楼2017-08-09 21:11:14
7楼2017-08-09 21:14:10
8楼2017-08-09 21:15:38
9楼2017-08-09 21:17:01
12楼2017-08-09 21:20:03
16楼2017-08-09 21:25:50
20楼2017-08-09 22:59:04
21楼2017-08-09 23:06:07
22楼2017-08-09 23:06:23
25楼2018-12-05 15:11:43
简单回复
2017-08-09 21:09
回复
郭梓歌(金币+1): 谢谢参与
祝福 发自小木虫Android客户端
看不尽的风景4楼
2017-08-09 21:09
回复
郭梓歌(金币+1): 谢谢参与
。 发自小木虫Android客户端
南男10楼
2017-08-09 21:17
回复
郭梓歌(金币+1): 谢谢参与
祝福 发自小木虫Android客户端
无痕但11楼
2017-08-09 21:19
回复
郭梓歌(金币+1): 谢谢参与
j 发自小木虫Android客户端
nono200913楼
2017-08-09 21:21
回复
郭梓歌(金币+1): 谢谢参与
祝福 发自小木虫Android客户端
wyq17614楼
2017-08-09 21:23
回复
郭梓歌(金币+1): 谢谢参与
嗯 发自小木虫Android客户端
wangli520815楼
2017-08-09 21:24
回复
郭梓歌(金币+1): 谢谢参与
祝福 发自小木虫IOS客户端
yaoyao14517楼
2017-08-09 21:26
回复
郭梓歌(金币+1): 谢谢参与
y 发自小木虫IOS客户端
sz_kebaoyuan18楼
2017-08-09 22:55
回复
郭梓歌(金币+1): 谢谢参与
逝水无痕199019楼
2017-08-09 22:57
回复
郭梓歌(金币+1): 谢谢参与
祝福 发自小木虫IOS客户端
baggiotalent23楼
2017-08-10 12:57
回复
郭梓歌(金币+1): 谢谢参与
