24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

Master-Fandy

铜虫 (小有名气)

应助: 1 (幼儿园)
金币: 2548.6
红花: 1
帖子: 213
在线: 70.2小时
虫号: 1459566
注册: 2011-10-25
性别: GG
专业: 药物化学

[交流] 论文大修后，投稿状态从with editor直接变成decision in process，神马情况……已有23人参与

各位虫友，大家好！
小妹前段时间投了一篇论文，一个多月收到一审意见——大修，大概花了两个星期的时间，该补的理论实验也补充了，个人感觉整体上满足了审稿人的要求。9月1日返修回去，当天状态就变成with editor，3天后状态直接变成decision in process，好像没有经过under review过程。麻烦各位虫友们，帮忙分析一下具体情况和原因，自己都莫名的恐慌和紧张……目前还没收到任何结果。

另附审稿意见如下：
Reviewer #1: Ursolic acid(UA), the derivative of oleanolic acid, is widely studied due to numerous pharmacological activities. The author had synthesized a series of ursolic acid derivatives, which is a break ground result. In this paper, simulation approach is employed to explore the effects of binding affinity for inhibitory activities, which is an innovative work for the study on anti-diabetic properties of the hydrolyzation analogues of UA.
While, in order to verify that simulation model can explain the experimental results, some work needs to be complemented
Major Issues:
1. In the section of “structure activity relationship”
The author had got the value of IC50 by experiments, and calculated the binding energy to understand the relationship between binding mode and bioactivity. While Quantitative Structure-Activity and Relationships (QSAR) is the only persuasive tool to explain which structures play the important role in enhancing the inhibition activity.
In order to increase the confidence level of simulation results, the author has to demonstrate the QSAR equations to support their conclusions. The math expression of QSAR equation can be obtained by regression analysis. Only after the regression analysis work is completed, we can know which site in UA plays the important role for inhibition activity.
2. In the section of “molecular docking mode”, the author only listed the calculation results, but no parameter settings. The author has to list the major parameters, such as which kind of force field, which algorithm were used
Minor Issues:
3. Typo: In Figure 1. 3a - 8a & 3b – 8b should be replaced by 3a - 10a & 3b – 10b
4. Use idiomatic English expression:
Line 1: November 14 ---> November 14th;
Line 29: Expose
5. Some abbreviate needs full name, such as: Line 92: DMSO

Reviewer #2: This manuscript reports the synthesis and evaluation of a group of ursolic acid derivatives for anti-diabetic applications. The authors presented in vitro anti-diabetic activity and modeling studies to demonstrate their structure-bioactivity relationships, which would be useful for developing more effective alpha-glucosidase inhibitors. The manuscript is also well-written. I would recommend an acceptance in PLOS One after minor revisions.
1. The authors need to discuss what are the rationals of the overall molecular structure design and what are the objectives and hypotheses between each group analysis for molecules of interest.
2. It would be helpful if the authors can briefly discuss about the control (Acarbose) selection, since there are so many available inhibitors out there.
3. In the caption of Fig. 4, "liphilic" should be "Lipophilic". The authors need to carefully check over the manuscript to avoid typos.

回复此楼