24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

hc5505479

新虫 (小有名气)

应助: 17 (小学生)
金币: 29.6
红花: 4
帖子: 169
在线: 566.2小时
虫号: 2220313
注册: 2013-01-03
专业: 计算机网络

[交流] 投稿PLOS One的问题已有2人参与

大家好，最近我投了一篇论文给PLOS One，3天后收到下面的信

Thank you for submitting your manuscript entitled "" to PLOS ONE.  Your manuscript files have been checked in house but before we can proceed, we need you to address the following issues:

1. Thank you for submitting your manuscript to PLOS ONE. Our editorial staff has assessed your submission, and we have determined that the quality of the English language, as well as other significant issues, need to be addressed before we can proceed with the review process. Addressing language and other issues at this stage ensures that the scientific content is assessed fairly by reviewers and also maintains the quality of published work, since PLOS ONE does not perform copyediting of manuscripts at any later stage in the publication process.

We ask that you please have your manuscript copy-edited by either a native-English speaking colleague or a professional copy-editing service.  While you may approach any qualified individual or any professional scientific editing service of your choice, PLOS has partnered with American Journal Experts (AJE) to provide discounted services to PLOS authors. AJE has extensive experience helping authors meet PLOS guidelines and can provide language editing, translation, manuscript formatting, and figure formatting to ensure your manuscript meets our submission guidelines. If there are still language issues in text that AJE has edited, AJE will re-edit the text for free. To take advantage of this special partnership, visit the AJE website and enter referral code PLOS15 on the registration page for a 15% discount off AJE services (https://www.aje.com/c/plos15). If you are already registered with AJE, please log in and enter PLOS15 at the bottom of your researcher dashboard under ‘Join a Group.’ Please note that PLOS ONE does not receive any compensation in relation to services completed by AJE and that having the manuscript copyedited by AJE or any other editing services does not guarantee selection for peer review. Your manuscript has not yet been considered for its scientific merits, we cannot do so unless the language is significantly improved.

Please note that PLOS ONE considers only primary scientific research and not purely theoretical research (such as pure mathematics), and it must be clear that your work contributes to the base of knowledge in the sciences. Therefore, during the editing process of your manuscript, we strongly urge you to include the following:

a. Specific details of methods and analysis
b. Elaboration of conclusions that can be drawn

There is also a concern that there may be insufficient validation of the results for this paper to be considered a full research article.

We cannot consider your manuscript until the language and other issues in it are addressed. Upon resubmission, please provide the name of the colleague or the details of the professional service that copyedited your manuscript. Please also submit a second copy of your manuscript showing your changes highlighted or using track changes. Please upload this as a *supporting information* file. (Please note that this will be deleted once the in-house Editor has confirmed that the issues above have been addressed.).

2. Please be aware that PLOS requires all data underlying the findings described in the manuscript to be freely available to other researchers. As part of our new policy, we require authors to confirm that all data are: (1) in the body of the manuscript; (2) in the supporting information; or (3) in a stable, public repository that provides an accession number or digital object identifier (DOI) for each dataset. If your data cannot be made publically available for ethical or legal reasons (e.g., public availability would compromise patient privacy or could represent some other threat such as specific locations of fossil deposits or endangered species), please explain this in your cover letter when you submit your revised manuscript. Also, please provide the contact information for the people or group readers may contact to request the data. We recommend that data be held by a data access or ethics committee to help ensure the data are adequately anonymized and will be available in the future. If this is not an option, please consider having multiple people hold the data.

If you cannot make your data publicly available because you received it from a third party, please provide details of the source and contact information that others can use to request the data.
For the full policy, please see https://www.plosone.org/static/policies#sharing. If you feel that you are unwilling or unable to adhere to this policy, please contact us as soon as possible.

Your paper will be reviewed by in-house editors who will verify that your manuscript meets our basic criteria and follows all journal policies before it is moved forward to review with an Academic Editor.

We thank you for your cooperation in this matter.

Your manuscript has been returned to your account. Please log on to PLOS Editorial Manager at https://pone.edmgr.com/ to access your manuscript.

Your manuscript can be found in the "Submissions Sent Back to Author" link under the New Submissions menu. After you have made the changes requested above, please be sure to view and approve the revised PDF after rebuilding the PDF to complete the resubmission process.

Please note that these changes have been requested to comply with submission guidelines and your manuscript will *not* be sent to review until you have fully adhered to our requests.  Once your paper has been seen by an Editor we may return it to you for further information or amendments.

Thank you for submitting your work to PLOS ONE.

Sincerely,
Fiona Service

[on behalf of]
Gina Alvino, PhD
Associate Editor, PLOS ONE

第2点我可以理解要公开数据，下次上传时我一并传上去就好了，但是在第1点修改语言后面有这么一段话：
Please note that PLOS ONE considers only primary scientific research and not purely theoretical research (such as pure mathematics), and it must be clear that your work contributes to the base of knowledge in the sciences. Therefore, during the editing process of your manuscript, we strongly urge you to include the following:

a. Specific details of methods and analysis
b. Elaboration of conclusions that can be drawn

There is also a concern that there may be insufficient validation of the results for this paper to be considered a full research article.

我是做计算机网络方面的，因为这篇论文写得不太好，所以才想试试PLOS One，但是编辑这样说的意思是不是PLOS One只收基础学科方向的文章，对于我们这种专业性比较强受众比较小的，实验数据是仿真得到的文章不太容易接受？请大家分享一下经验搞计算机网络方面的投这个好中么？

回复此楼