24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

daihuanjob

新虫 (初入文坛)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 2
帖子: 5
在线: 6.4小时
虫号: 2195379
注册: 2012-12-19

[求助] IEEE Signal Processing Letters　RE-SUBMISSION OF A REJECTED MANUSCRIPT已有2人参与

1月16日，投搞IEEE　Signal Processing Letters
3月3号，收到decision. REJECT.

两个审稿人，一个小修接收，一个拒稿。
编辑整理的意见如下：
In summary, the reviewers point out deficiencies of the paper which prevent it from being accepted. Both reviewers note that insufficient detail is provided about the proposed approach; consequently the results are not reproducible. In addition, the reviewers note that the choice of method specifics is not sufficiently well-motivated. Reviewer 1 points out that the choice of NN parameters (number of hidden layers, number of nodes per hidden layer) are not well-motivated. Reviewer 2 points out that the choice of using a NN in general is not sufficiently well-motivated, and the performance evaluation does not compare with other state-of-the-art methods.

Considering that the decision process for the IEEE Signal Processing Letters is BINARY (papers that need major revisions are not accepted), I regret that I cannot offer you a more positive decision at this point because we do appreciate your interest in publishing in the IEEE Signal Processing Letters.

Resubmission of Previously Rejected Manuscripts: Technically, you cannot resubmit a REJECTED manuscript, as it is a REJECTED and CLOSED paper. You would therefore need to submit it as a new manuscript obtaining a new manuscript ID #, following the guidelines in the Author Center (where you would submit your paper to the system) under "RE-SUBMISSION OF A REJECTED MANUSCRIPT"

Authors of Rejected manuscripts are allowed to resubmit their manuscripts only once. The Signal Processing Society strongly discourages resubmission of rejected manuscripts more than once. At the time of submission, you will be asked whether you consider your manuscript to be a new submission or a resubmission of an earlier Rejected manuscript. If you choose to submit a new version of your manuscript, you will be asked to submit supporting documents detailing how your new version addresses all of the reviewers' comments. Full details of the resubmission process can be found in the Signal Processing Society “Policy and Procedures Manual” at http://www.signalprocessingsociety.org/about/governance/policy-procedure/

Note that resubmitting your manuscript does not guarantee eventual acceptance, and that your resubmission will be subject to re-review by the reviewers before a decision is rendered. Also note that the original Associate Editor who managed the original peer review process is not guaranteed as well. Resubmissions are to be treated as brand new submissions without bias.

还请有经验的朋友给点意见。
是修改重投，还是改投其他期刊？

回复此楼