24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

yyman660

木虫 (著名写手)

应助: 35 (小学生)
贵宾: 0.227
金币: 1603.4
散金: 1092
红花: 15
帖子: 1410
在线: 152.5小时
虫号: 969628
注册: 2010-03-13
性别: GG
专业: 半导体电子器件

[交流] 二审修改稿投出去了, 继续祈福中,每个虫子3个金币, 中了再散200！已有1人参与

二审修改了半个月，终于把修改稿投出了，继续祈福，但愿顺利！每个虫子仨金币了！中了再散金200！

----------华丽的分割线------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
二审意见回来了，改成Minor revision了，但是审稿人还是在纠结一个技术问题，给了一个月修改时间，继续发金币祈福，每人2个，麻烦各位虫子回复字数多一点，免得被系统判为简单回复，没法发金币，多谢各位虫友！中了再追加200金币

Reviewer Comments:
Reviewer #1 Evaluations:
RECOMMENDATION: Publish in APL with mandatory revision (minor)
Paper Interesting: Yes
Original Paper: Yes
Sufficient Physics: Yes
Well Organized: Yes
Clear and Error Free: Yes
Conclusions Supported: Yes
Appropriate Title: Yes
Good Abstract: Yes
Satisfactory English: Yes
Adequate References: Yes
Clear Figures: Yes
OVERALL RATING: Very Good

----------华丽的分割线------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

APL初审意见如下，审稿人提的几个意见已经逐条回复了, 目前正在二审中，最担心的就是初审意见中的original paper: No, 这可是关键标准啊，不知道审稿人能不能善心大发，给我改成yes，已经11天了，各种忐忑，散300金币祈福，中了再散200！！！

ps，哪位大神遇到过original paper： no的情况么，求交流

初审意见
Reviewer Comments:
Reviewer #1 Evaluations:
RECOMMENDATION: Reconsider for APL after mandatory revision (major)
Paper Interesting: Yes
Original Paper: No
Sufficient Physics: Yes
Well Organized: Yes
Clear and Error Free: Yes
Conclusions Supported: No
Appropriate Title: No
Good Abstract: Yes
Satisfactory English: Yes
Adequate References: No
Clear Figures: Yes
OVERALL RATING: Good

二审进度
All Reviewers Secured 20-Feb-2015 11:52:26
Review Started 20-Feb-2015 11:52:26
First Reviewer Secured 20-Feb-2015 11:52:26
Potential Reviewer Agreed to Review 20-Feb-2015 11:52:26
Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 11-Feb-2015 21:27:22
Potential Reviewers Selected 11-Feb-2015 21:27:08
Reviewer Assignment Started 11-Feb-2015 12:14:36
Securing Associate Editor 11-Feb-2015 12:14:35
Securing Editor 11-Feb-2015 12:14:35
Submission Check by Editorial Office Completed 11-Feb-2015 12:14:35
Submission Check by Editorial Office Started 11-Feb-2015 10:24:10
Securing Editor 11-Feb-2015 10:24:10
Manuscript Submitted to Editorial Office 11-Feb-2015 10:24:09
Awaiting Author Adjustment/Approval of Converted Files 11-Feb-2015 09:12:36
Submission Check by Editorial Office Failed 11-Feb-2015 09:12:36
Submission Check by Editorial Office Started 11-Feb-2015 01:39:58
Securing Editor 11-Feb-2015 01:39:58
Manuscript Submitted to Editorial Office 11-Feb-2015 01:39:56
Preliminary Manuscript Data Submitted 10-Feb-2015 22:28:59

[ Last edited by yyman660 on 2015-3-25 at 22:58 ]

三审都21天了，还没结果，忐忑啊~~~~(>_<

~~~~

[ Last edited by yyman660 on 2015-4-24 at 20:03 ]

附上三审进度--三审整整拖了28天啊！
----------华丽的分割线------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Manuscript Sent to Production 01-May-2015 10:24:33
Manuscript Ready for Production 30-Apr-2015 22:51:54
Decision Sent to Author 30-Apr-2015 22:51:54
Decision Letter Being Prepared 30-Apr-2015 21:36:15
Associate Editor Decision Completed 30-Apr-2015 21:36:15
Associate Editor Decision Started 30-Apr-2015 20:46:47
All Reviews Received 30-Apr-2015 20:46:47
Review Received 30-Apr-2015 20:46:47
All Reviewers Secured 02-Apr-2015 14:43:24
Review Started 02-Apr-2015 14:43:24
First Reviewer Secured 02-Apr-2015 14:43:24
Potential Reviewer Agreed to Review 02-Apr-2015 14:43:24
Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 26-Mar-2015 00:44:09
Potential Reviewers Selected 26-Mar-2015 00:43:58
Reviewer Assignment Started 25-Mar-2015 10:27:19
Securing Associate Editor 25-Mar-2015 10:27:19
Securing Editor 25-Mar-2015 10:27:19
Submission Check by Editorial Office Completed 25-Mar-2015 10:27:19
Submission Check by Editorial Office Started 25-Mar-2015 09:51:50
Securing Editor 25-Mar-2015 09:51:50
Manuscript Submitted to Editorial Office 25-Mar-2015 09:51:49
Preliminary Manuscript Data Submitted 25-Mar-2015 09:06:33

[ Last edited by yyman660 on 2015-5-3 at 00:40 ]

附上三审结果，publish in APL as is....
----------华丽的分割线------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Editor's Comments:
Reviewer Comments:
Reviewer #1 Evaluations:
RECOMMENDATION: Publish in APL as is
Paper Interesting: Yes
Original Paper: Yes
Sufficient Physics: Yes
Well Organized: Yes
Clear and Error Free: Yes
Conclusions Supported: Yes
Appropriate Title: Yes
Good Abstract: Yes
Satisfactory English: Yes
Adequate References: Yes
Clear Figures: Yes
OVERALL RATING: Very Good

Applied Physics Letters retains the top spot as the most highly cited journal in Applied Physics with an Impact Factor of 3.515

[ Last edited by yyman660 on 2015-5-3 at 00:42 ]

APL终于中了，从major到minor到accept as is,加上中途修改，总共历时144天，再加上老板那里压了俩月，总共搞了大半年，还好终于中了，也算给这半年工作有个交代，也祝大家paper顺利！手头有篇OE要审，明天提几个问题就给他过了，哈哈

[ Last edited by yyman660 on 2015-5-3 at 00:46 ]

回复此楼